DDF review: What’s the Harm?
By Chris Somers
The grandiosity of the debating chamber created a palpably solemn atmosphere ahead of the start of What’s the Harm?. The weight and sensitivity of the play’s subject matter meant that it was a bold and ambitious endeavour with potential for succumbing to cliché, or else risking an unenjoyable and uncomfortable experience for the audience. However, the outstanding strength of the script and the quality of the acting meant that Alex Prescot’s play was nothing short of a triumph.
What’s the Harm? was undoubtedly a distressing affair. The play centres around the trial of two teachers accused of sexual involvement with female students. The judge, portrayed by Ellie Gauge, ponders over the verdicts she passed on these seemingly similar, but vastly different cases. The intensity and poignance of Gauge’s delivery was integral to the play’s effectiveness.
The story unfolds in the form of a series of flashbacks as the victims and the accused give their testimonies. This format was very effective, and meant that the piece maintained an enticing momentum for its duration. Indeed, it is testament to the quality of Alex Prescot’s writing that the story was so dynamic, but at the same time was very easy to follow, aided by a creative use of lighting to distinguish between the play’s elements.
The acting was exceptional throughout. Both Jack Fenwick as the malicious Mr Canton and Matt Todd as Mr Richards gave strong and believable performances which allowed the audience to consider the extent of each man’s guilt as the characters developed. Izzie Price portrayed the manipulative Tracy confidently and effectively, interacting wonderfully with Todd as their characters’ relationship progressed. It was, however, Jenny Walser who gave the play’s stand out performance with her effortless and completely captivating portrayal of the naive and innocent Bella.
Alex Prescot, along with his production team and excellent cast, succeeded in creating a play that was dauntless, and yet included sufficient nuance and moral debate to mean that it was both poignant and enthralling.
Photograph: Alex Prescot

