How not to organise a PCC election

by Chris Somers

Thursday 15th November was a disastrous day for British democracy. It was the first chance for the public to vote for candidates to become inaugural police and crime commissioners.

A little under 15% of the eligible population turned out to do so, in what was the greatest show of national apathy seen in any major election in England and Wales. At a polling station in Cardiff South, just two votes were cast. Elsewhere, the now infamous Bettws ward in Newport, Gwent didn’t see a single ballot paper completed.

From a turnout of 14.4% in Durham, 51.6% of the vote went to Labour Party candidate Ron Hogg, who has been appointed to the new position ahead of independent candidate Kingsley Smith, Mike Costello of UKIP, and the Conservative Nick Varley.

Like his 40 elected colleagues chosen to lead forces up and down the country, it is now Mr Hogg’s responsibility to set the strategic priorities of the police, as well as hiring and firing chief constables and deciding on budgets.

So why did such an embarrassingly small turnout occur? Surely a primary reason is that there seemed to be an astonishing lack of public information available about the election itself, or the candidates running, or even what exactly the role of police and crime commissioner involved.

For a reason known only to the government, candidates were denied the free mailshot traditionally granted during elections, meaning that campaigning was to be more challenging even from the offset.

Furthermore, the prime minister, who had hailed the introduction of police commissioners as a key act of reform during the 2010 general election campaign, seemed to do very little himself to publicise an election which was, after all, one of his big steps towards a more localised political system.

“There seemed to be an astonishing lack of public information available about the election itself, or the candidates running…”

The timing of this election also seems to have contributed to the whole exercise being a flop. Would it not have been sensible to run the vote alongside another major election – perhaps those for local councils next May – to encourage more (or indeed any) people to visit a polling station?

This decision would also no doubt have reduced the cost involved. It should be noted at this point that the election cost ÂŁ75 million, or ÂŁ14 for every vote cast. Throw in a general lack of media interest and good old-fashioned public contempt for excessive bureaucracy, and it becomes apparent why fewer people than tune in to an average episode of Eastenders turned out to vote.

Perhaps it should be considered what exactly it was we were supposedly voting for. The 41 men and women now installed as PCCs enjoy a significant amount of power over police forces throughout England and Wales.

The idea is apparently that the needs of people on a local level will now be heard and taken into consideration, but what about the other side of the story?

While I’m not suggesting the threat of an Article 48 situation, it simply can’t be reasonable to place the responsibility of running a police force into one person’s hands. It seems that the crime-fighting efficiency and effectiveness of the police is being gambled with.

Moreover, this appointment of PCCs has meant a further politicalisation of the police. By having candidates affiliated with political parties running for election, the contest became one of party politics, whereas it should have been a contest based on individual ideas and merit.

Finally, we should consider the police force itself. Barely back on its feet following of a governmental slash of public spending, British policing finds itself yet again the subject of political interference. The government has committed to police reform, yet seems to have created more problems than solutions.

In the current climate of confrontation from police representative bodies over issues such as pay and pensions, this interference can only have created further uncertainty and unrest within police forces nationwide, compromising their ability to serve their purpose.