DUCK expeditions help us, not the poor
by James Murray
Dear DUCK,
As you may be aware there have been a number of criticisms levelled against the activities you organise. This letter expresses concerns surrounding the purpose and effectiveness of some of your programmes. Specifically it is a call to replace the expeditions with a programme of exchanges.
The holiday-with-a-conscience culture of charity that has become associated with the expeditions is ruinous both to the image of DUCK and the good intentions of those involved.
As far as I am aware participants spend 4-5 weeks abroad split between volunteering and holidaying. The fees include a £1,300 donation to charity. The work carried out ranges from conservation work to building work and teaching. I assume the expeditions aim to improve the situation of the communities concerned by both the financial donation and voluntary work.
As concerns the latter, I don’t think it should be contentious to assert that the volunteer is by far the greatest beneficiary. I cannot help but think the building jobs wouldn’t better go to the local unemployed and the teaching jobs to local teachers. If the volunteers’ sole concern was the project the donation would suffice, instead of paying for the extravagant travel costs.
Nevertheless there is value in travelling and meeting people from different cultures. The value, however, comes from the development of mutual respect and understanding. It is a process whereby both sides learn. This goal is only obfuscated if the idea that one side is giving and the other receiving – rather than establishing a platform of mutual reciprocity.
As regards the donation there is a danger that it becomes merely a way to give an extravagant holiday a conscience. In an almost hackneyed critique of charity Zizek quotes Oscar Wilde who argues that charity runs the risk of merely concealing the true problems from us. He argues that it was the slave owners who were nice to their slaves that were the worst because it allowed an evil system to appear more humane.
Though it is not so simple, a parallel can be drawn. In a global society where the bottom billion are starving and the top billion are obese the causal relationship is undeniable. These expeditions only address the symptoms of poverty, not the causes – they make a bad system seem better.
However not only does pampering poverty in this way distract from initiating real change, which is not in itself an insurmountable task, but that it does so by the very same extravagant living which causes the initial inequality. It would be like the slave master enslaving more people to ensure his slaves are well looked after.
If the aim is to alleviate poverty the way we must do this is by establishing a society which precludes poverty rather than pampers it – in the same way that the solution to slavery was to abolish it not to pamper the slaves.
That is not to say we should wait for a revolution but rather that we must take steps within our own community to restructure our society. For example, instead of flying to Tanzania to build water towers we should campaign against the land grabs by European businesses which are preventing access to water in the first place.
It does not seem appropriate for DUCK to lend the label of charity (which it must use with responsibility) to the indulgence of students wishing to holiday, travel, “swim with dolphins, go scuba diving, visit stone town or just spend your time sipping cocktails and eating some of the world’s best seafood on the white sandy beach” as the website states. Using the symptoms of poverty to facilitate these activities does not seem entirely moral.
Instead let’s establish a programme of exchanges to these countries where participants go with the aim of learning, sharing and understanding a different culture and the mechanisms which contribute to poverty and injustice. In this way participants have access to those all important cultural exchanges which can inspire us to work within our community to demand change.
As a country with global influence, it is by changing our own society that we can create a future where poverty is impossible – not pampered.

