Could Taiwo Ayoniyi’s injury have been prevented?

By Joe Jenkinson

On Sunday 11th May, Nottingham Forest forward, Taiwo Awoniyi, collided with the post in the dying minutes of a 2-2 draw against Leicester City. Despite being cleared by the medical staff to continue playing, Awoniyi was later rushed into hospital with a ruptured intestine, resulting in him being placed into an induced coma. Whilst there are obvious question marks over why the centre forward was allowed to remain on the field, could the whole thing have been avoided with a simple offside call?

The Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL) instruct that linesmen and women should refrain from calling immediate offsides to allow outcomes of attacking phases of play to be retrospectively considered by the Video Assistant Referee (VAR). In effect, this should allow Hawk-Eye, and the recently introduced semi-automated offside technology, to accurately determine the legality of any eventual important outcome. In 2019, the Premier League stated that, “When an immediate goalscoring opportunity is likely to occur and there is a tight, marginal offside call, the assistant referee should keep their flag down”.  With the added ‘safety net’ of VAR, this law prevents goals being incorrectly disallowed. A perfect example of this was shown in the recent Brighton and Hove Albion game against Liverpool. After Jack Hinshelwood had put the ball into the net, the assistant referee flagged for an offside offence in the build-up. Following a VAR check, the goal was subsequently deemed valid.

“When an immediate goalscoring opportunity is likely to occur and there is a tight, marginal offside call, the assistant referee should keep their flag down”

However, as is often the case, the subjective nature of football throws a spanner in the works. Anyone that saw the incident, and understands the offside rule, should clearly be able to tell that Anthony Elanga was offside as he received the ball that would eventually be crossed into the box for Awoniyi to try and meet. Nottingham Forest full-back, Ola Aina, told the Mail that “Anthony was miles offside. The whole world could see and so could I from where I was”.  Yet, in the heat of the moment, in what was a must-win game for Nottingham Forest, Sian Massey-Ellis allowed play to continue, honouring the aforementioned laws to a degree that is commonplace in Premier League matches week in week out.

Football fans, and in particular Nottingham Forest fans, find discomfort in the fact that this specific phase of play was not “tight” nor “marginal”, yet play continued and Awoniyi consequently became seriously injured.  Should Massey-Ellis have flagged for offside there would have been no qualms, equally should play have continued and Awoniyi had scored, it would have, hopefully, taken VAR seconds to rule the goal offside. Unfortunately,  due to the shocking revelation that Awoniyi, who is adored for his efforts in retaining Forest’s Premier League status, was to undergo major surgery, fans have called for the rule to be scrapped.

Despite these calls, BBC Sport suggests there were no immediate indications that the law would be changed in light of Awoniyi’s injury. Whilst this protection of the law will keep ensuring valid goals are not prematurely disallowed, there must be a consensus that clear and obvious offsides should be immediately flagged to ensure the welfare of those on the field. Forest, known for their tendencies to rightly or wrongly publicly question the PGMOL, are said to have opened up an internal review, intent on understanding why play was allowed to continue.

Forest, known for their tendencies to rightly or wrongly publicly question the PGMOL, are said to have opened up an internal review

Perhaps unsurprisingly, given the Forest owner’s temperamental nature, Evangelos Marinakis found himself in animated conversation with NFFC head coach, Nuno Espirito Santo, on the City Ground pitch post-match. With an overperforming Forest side appearing to fade away from once strong Champions League security, there was reasonable criticism directed towards the Forest owner for being overly critical. Whilst some notable pundits were quick to offer Nuno career advice, Nottingham Forest later produced a statement on behalf of Mr Marinakis, supporting his “emotional investment” and “shared frustration between all of us that the medical team should never have allowed the player to continue”.

If we are to believe the statement from Forest, the effect of the decision to allow play to continue was clearly emotionally triggering. Combine this with the medical staff’s decision that Awoniyi was fit to continue, a very unfortunate episode of events played out on the banks of the River Trent. This emotion has been echoed in the support Awoniyi has received, across social media and amongst the Forest camp. Before kick-off in Forest’s most recent Premier League game away at West Ham, the Nigerian international broke his silence, stating he was on the mend and offered his full support to Forest in what is set up to be a dramatic end to the season.

With Morgan Gibbs-White, Nottingham Forest attacking midfielder, raising an Awoniyi shirt during his goal celebration at the London Stadium, it was hard not to think that this all could have been avoided.

Image: Steffen Prossdrof via Wikimedia Commons