England’s T20 tour of India: Bazball takes on the white ball

By Joe Jenkinson

July 2024 saw a departure from the England white ball set up, as head coach Andrew Mott stepped down from his duties. England red ball head coach and founder of ‘Bazball’, Brendan McCullum, replaced him, with his tenure beginning in January. This saw Rob Key, managing director of the England cricket team, perform a U-turn on his 2022 decision to split the head coach duties up across the formats; a choice that was perhaps symptomatic of the lack of success post-2022.

McCullum’s first challenge comprised of a 20-over tour of India in January 2025 where England will have hoped to squash past grievances in the white ball format. The humiliation of the 2023 ODI World Cup, hosted on Indian soil, and the defeat to the Men in Blue in the 2024 T20 World Cup semi-final are still very much open wounds. Now, we look to McCullum to turn the Three Lions back into a white ball superpower. A good series in India would have been an encouraging statement.

On January 22nd, Eden Gardens, Kolkata, awaited for the first of five T20 fixtures. A far from unrecognisable England XI took to the field, batting first. Openers Phil Salt and Ben Duckett became victim to the skilful pace of Arshdeep Singh, adding only four to the total between them. Captain Jos Butler got good value from 44 balls, adding 68 to the total. However, the irony of tricky leg-spinner Varun Chakravarthy being so successful under McCullum for the Kolkata Knight Riders was painfully evident as he claimed three big scalps of Harry Brook, Liam Livingstone, and Jos Butler. Ultimately, England got dismissed for a measly 132 which India chased in the fastest of fashions; a cocktail of destructive batting from Abhishek Sharma and lax English catching put India one-nil up in the series: a disappointing start.

Chennai awaited next. Jamie Smith and Brydon Carse replaced Jacob Bethell and Gus Atkinson in what was a much tighter affair. England padded up first once more and manged to add just 32 more runs to their Kolkata total. Butler was the pick of the bunch again, falling just short of yet another T20 half century. Carse’s 31 from 17 balls was a hint at McCullum’s plan for attractive all-rounders, albeit to no avail in the outcome. India chased the English total of 164, thanks to a fine innings from Tilak Varma. Carse picked up three as India finished eight down, but the failure of England to post a competitive score proved pivotal again.  

There is no doubt that that ‘Bazball’ is an attractive style, but it got picked apart in India, where IPL experience and inexperience was evident.

Rajkot saw an elusive victory for England, who once again batted first on a spinners deck. Explosive batting from Duckett, 51 from 28, and Livingstone, 43 from 24, saw England post their largest total of the series: 171. Varun shone once more, destroying the soft English middle order and taking a five-for. Whilst not taking the same amount of wickets, Adil Rashid showed his leg break experience with an economy of just 3.75, muffling the Indian reply excellently. This opened the door for the English pacemen to take wickets, with Jamie Overton taking three to seal a 26 run victory. A sign of things to come or a mere consolation?

In Pune, England finally won the toss and elected to field, restrict India, and level the series. Saqib Mahmood dismissed the top order with ease, getting a triple wicket maiden in the second over of the game. However, unlike the English middle order, Shivam Dube and Hardik Pandya displayed some thrilling power hitting, scoring 50s each and propelling the Indian total to 181. Salt and Duckett set a good platform for England in response and Brook continued an impressive top order performance, striking at 196 to score 51 quickly. However, a worryingly typical middle order slump ensued and England were bowled out for 166 in the 20th over: 3-1 India, and defeat.

With victory in the series unachievable, England looked for a result in Mumbai to be proud of. This was certainly not the case. India batted first, and that man Abhishek produced a breathtaking knock. His 135 runs from 54 balls, consisting of seven fours and thirteen sixes, is now the second fastest hundred in full member T20 Internationals. After 20 overs, India reached a gargantuan total of 247, with the game all but lost. Abhishek himself scored 38 more runs than England’s 97 all-out and the series ended with a 4-1 victory to India.

Prior to his first white ball series with England, BBC Sport reported McCullum’s promise of a “watchable brand of cricket”. There is no doubt that that ‘Bazball’ is an attractive style, but it got picked apart in India, where IPL experience and inexperience was evident. McCullum sees value in his all-rounders and middle order batters but, bar a few rare moments, they were inconsistent and lacked influence. It must be known that we are judging this new England outfit on the toughest of stages, but this is where we must be succeeding if we wish to get back to former glory.

Image: Storm Machine via Wikimedia Commons