Remembering men of letters, in the letters of men

By Bilal Junejo

No one who is drawn to English literature since the reign of Queen Victoria can have (long) endured the misfortune of not knowing who Charles Lutwidge Dodgson was. His renown is too great to admit of such woeful ignorance. Nearly anyone who lived without knowing Dodgson died long before he did. If you suspect — and perchance not a little resentfully — that the fame of which I speak may not be as universal as I have declared it to be, permit me to assure you that most people (if not nearly all) have no idea that it is the gentleman in question to whom they owe what mirth is theirs when(ever) they think of Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland. Lewis Carroll was the pseudonym of a man whose Alice had been inspired by the daughter of the dean of Christ Church (the college at Oxford where Dodgson was a lecturer in mathematics), Alice Liddell.

Dodgson’s fondness for Alice knew no more bounds than the fascination of generations since with the Wonderland and the Looking Glass. His life, however, has been recorded elsewhere with too much ability to justify any recapitulation of them on this occasion. So I propose it would constitute a more sensible use of our time to proceed forthwith taking a look at another document which the author of these words, with his sworn devotion to Clio, has been suffered to rescue from that obscurity with which the callous indifference of society is wont to bless the contents of even its most promising archives.

Nearly anyone who lived without knowing Dodgson died long before he did

In The Times of 2 January 1932, there appears a letter entitled “Lewis Carroll” (and written, we can only presume, to commemorate the centenary of Dodgson’s birth), in which its author, Harry R. Mileham (of Burlingham, Mallory-road, Hove), observes

“Sir,— Just possibly the following incident may be of interest as a side-light on the character of Lewis Carroll.

In the summer of about the year 1880, when seven years old and on a visit with relations to Eastbourne, my playmate was a girl cousin of the same age. On one of our low-tide explorations of the chalk-rock pools this cousin slipped and fell full-length in a few inches of water. Refusing to see the funny side of the incident and regarding with dismay her sodden garments, she set up a piercing howl, which no words of mine were able to abate. From the distant crowded parade emerged a black-coated figure of clerical aspect, striding in haste over shingle and sand-flat. Gathering up in his arms the wet mess of my amphibious cousin, he bore her with soothing words to the lodgings where she would be. It was somehow borne in upon me that I was probably the cause of the trouble, and that, anyhow, little boys were of no account, unless conceivably the getting in a mess and making an inordinate fuss should render them of interest to the gentleman who I now learned was the author of ‘Alice in Wonderland’. Next year my cousin was asked to stay, as one of a number of similar ‘Alices’, at some sort of holiday-home over which the Rev. Mr. Dodgson presided. These visits continued for some years, until the time came when her mother considered that the child’s ear for the King’s English was suffering through the rather mixed company.”

It seems to me that anyone who has been born great, or achieved greatness (or even had it thrust upon them), seem lovably near whenever you read of those rare occasions on which the Fates have seen fit to decree they should descend to conquer ordinary hearts. As even the fullest moon offers but a trace of the sun’s majesty, so the tribute of one whose privilege it has been to be the object, direct or otherwise, of renown’s unfeigned solicitude obliges you to wonder what greatness it must have taken to inspire homage which is, above all, posthumous — and able to elevate even higher any majesty that had seemed already to have reached its pinnacle.

“one of the secrets of life is that all that is really worth the doing is what we do for others.”

This is my theory, but I do not know how far it can be said to apply in the case of Mr Mileham and the subject of his epistle. I am in no position to say whether the ‘Rev. Mr. Dodgson’ embodied the greatness to which I have above adverted, which all lovers of his genius would believe was his, and about which it would be anyone’s pleasure to effuse. I suspect, however, that it would also be natural to suppose he had, for reasons too obvious to state, no need in the world of being kind in order to be praised. This leaves one to conclude that if it had genuinely been his intention to be nothing but kind on that day, it would afford those of us who have already been made despondent by our own cynicism (however well-meaning) to find such a beautifully unexpected opportunity of dwelling upon the truth that there is no soul in this world which can be suffered to lose the goodness that inheres in it without its own deliberate consent.

It was, after all, Carroll himself who said that “one of the secrets of life is that all that is really worth the doing is what we do for others.” And if you are reading this, you have really done something for me.

Image credit: Wikipedia Commons