Climate and the Conservative leadership candidates — are they as green as they say?

By Imogen Ellis

Despite the fiery debate between Liz Truss and Rishi Sunak throughout the Conservative leadership election, discussions on climate have yet to really heat up. Instead, Sunak and Truss have found themselves entrenched in an almost entirely economic discussion, focused on the costs and benefits of tax cuts in response to the UK’s cost of living crisis. 

Truss and Sunak’s limited focus on climate policy is perhaps unsurprising when considering their target electorate. A YouGov poll conducted in April of this year revealed that Conservative Party members ranked trying to hit the net-zero target as 10th in a list of their top 10 priorities. Winning the next election, controlling immigration, and cost of living support ranked highest for party members and unquestionably this is reflected in the content of the candidates’ debates. 

Conservative Party members ranked trying to hit the net-zero target as 10th in a list of their top 10 priorities

That being said, both Sunak and Truss have acknowledged climate change. Sunak came out stronger, stating his commitment to the 2050 net-zero target and reiterated that net-zero is a key component of the Conservative manifesto. Truss, on the other hand, wishes to “reconsider” some net-zero policies and has pledged to scrap the ‘green levy’ currently placed on energy bills. The BBC’s widely criticised climate question in the July TV debate; ‘What three things should people change in their lives to help tackle climate change faster?’, did little to flesh out either candidate’s green policy. Instead perhaps, the best way to understand each contender’s attitude to climate is through their voting record. 

Liz Truss champions herself as “an environmentalist before it was fashionable” and yet, her voting record paints a somewhat different picture. In September 2020, she voted against requiring ministers to have “due regard” for the net-zero’s 2050 target in policy and also not to include a “climate and nature emergency impact statement” for financial assistance proposals. Truss also placed limited emphasis on climate policy when in senior positions in Government – as Environment Secretary (2014-2016), she cut subsidies for solar power, citing concerns over food security, and publicly supported the expansion of Heathrow Airport. As Foreign Secretary, Truss proposed that aid should be directed away from climate change, and instead towards women and girls. Controversially, she has also been accused of disregarding the agreements made at the Paris Climate Accords in her UK-Australia trade deal – a claim she vehemently denies. Looking forward, Truss’ main climate agenda so far appears to be the removal of green levies on energy bills. A move that, however temporary, will reduce investment in renewable energy sources in the short term. 

Liz Truss champions herself as “an environmentalist before it was fashionable”

Rishi Sunak’s voting record is not hugely dissimilar to Truss’ when it comes to the environment. In 2016, Sunak voted against a decarbonisation target for the UK and in 2015, voted to apply the “climate change levy” to renewably-generated electricity. Sunak has also voted against asking the government to plan to erase most transport emissions by 2030 and as Chancellor. As Chancellor, Sunak was frequently accused of limiting the climate agenda. He spearheaded a reduction in fuel duty, removed climate issues from the 2021 budget and his 2022 Spring Windfall tax, excluded taxation on oil and gas companies. Conversely, Sunak did introduce a VAT reduction for people installing sustainable technologies like heat pumps and solar panels in homes. Unlike Truss, Sunak is committed to the net-zero target, however, a concrete plan for a successful energy transition is yet to materialise.

In short, both Truss and Sunak sit against the backdrop of a voting record that is generally against action to prevent climate change, and their future green policies do not suggest a drastic diversion from this pattern of thinking. So, as Sunak and Truss debate ‘What would Margret Thatcher do?’ on live TV, the issue of the climate remains somewhat side-lined. With a poll in April finding that ditching commitments to net-zero by 2050 would lose Tories 1.3 million votes in a general election, will Truss and Sunak’s absentee approach to climate be a short-term win with long-term consequences? What will happen when either becomes PM and has to face a more climate-conscious electorate in two years’ time?

Image credit: Garry Knight via Wikimedia Commons