Durham Women FC: reaching adulthood
By George Simms
How should we evaluate Durham Women FC’s 2021/22 season? 6th in the FA Women’s Championship is the Wildcats’ lowest finish since 2015, and 28 goals conceded is their highest since 2015 too. Yet they were top with eight games played, second at Christmas, and third with just three games to play.
Crowd sizes have grown exponentially and the Wildcats are building a dependable and dedicated support base after their second season at Maiden Castle. October’s sell-out thriller against Manchester United Women saw the club smash their all-time attendance record, and their league attendance record fell against both Liverpool and Sunderland.
A football club’s identity is forged by its history, by the memories and moments which define it. If a human year equates to seven dog years, a Durham Women year is about two human years by my calculations. Having just finished their ninth season, the Wildcats are entering adulthood.
Since their formation, the club have looked around the world in wide-eyed wonder. Their every move has been met with fulsome praise and rivals and critics have agreed that they definitely couldn’t do the same at that age. Constant progression up the league table has been matched by blind optimism off it – the belief that the sky is the limit, the only way is up.
The 2021/22 season breaks a trend of steady progress for the Wildcats going back as far as 2017’s Spring Series. 5th, 4th, 4th, 3rd, 2nd…. 6th was not the plan. Lee Sanders’s plucky upstarts are supposed to constantly push on, astonishing fans and oppositions alike with their overperformance despite limited resources and no men’s team to fall back on.
Adulthood is a scary prospect, and one that bears down on you at an alarming rate. The decision to move to a full-time training regime will see the club lose some of its key figures, with Abby Holmes and Nicki Gears already moving across the Wear to Sunderland, but it is a step the club needed to take to continue their growth.
As every good teenager does, Durham will make, and have made, mistakes
Four of the five teams who finished above Durham this season either train full-time or are fully professional. The Wildcats had to either accept that mid-table mediocrity was the best they could hope for, or make the change to restart their Newtonian perpetual motion upwards.
As every good teenager does, Durham will make, and have made, mistakes. There will inevitably be growing pains, but it is time for Durham to have those fundamental, formative experiences that separate adolescent from adult. Despite technically losing on penalties, that 2-2 Conti Cup clash with United will go down as the season’s highlight for the 1,468 fans who were there.
The club needs moments like Beth Hepple’s late equaliser under the lights to continue discovering who they are both on and off the pitch. A fanbase and club identity are built on The Big Moments. They morph into a mythology which warms the terraces on freezing December afternoons and is passed throughout generations.
Durham also need moments like the 1-0 loss to Coventry and the 3-3 draw with Watford. Club culture is a favourite buzz-phrase of the sports writing industry. No-one can quite define it, but they are sure that Real Madrid and Brighton’s are excellent, and Manchester United’s is utterly hopeless. To my mind, a club’s identity is built on the big moments, but its culture is developed in these seemingly insignificant ties.
The Wildcats need to find a way to win when nothing is going their way. Lee Sanders can spend as long as he wants drilling tactical systems into his side, but it is only through experience that his young club and players will really learn. To get out of this division, a practically perfect season is required. Durham can only hope to do that by learning how to win in all conditions.
You would have to be mad or blind to call Beth Hepple a problem for the Wildcats, but an overreliance on their star player has been obvious since the club’s inception. Durham’s record appearance-maker, creator and goalscorer, Hepple had another exceptional season, with ten goals and eight assists.
2021/22 was Hepple’s seventh double-digit goalscoring haul in all competitions in nine seasons, with only one other Wildcat having managed it even once (Molly Sharpe in 2019/20). This season, if Hepple was closed down in open-play, or the set-pieces didn’t quite go Durham’s way, then they often looked toothless going forward.
January signing Rio Hardy looked to provide a potential answer, but injuries and a cup-tie meant she often struggled for consistent game time. Bridget Galloway is brilliant on her day, but often looks isolated and short on ideas. Having missed only five of Durham Women’s games since their inception, it is impossible to say what the club would look like without Hepple, but an injury could be catastrophic for the side’s progress. They need creative reinforcements.
At the back, 28 goals conceded in the league was nearly double last season’s total and the club’s highest since the 2015 WSL 2. Given the basically unchanged backline from one season to another, this appears to be a consequence of other teams improving as they move to full-time training and full-blown professionalism. Now Durham have announced they are making this step, it looks hopeful that Maiden Castle can become a fortress once more.
With their toes over the precipice of monumental change, the Wildcats must keep their balance or risk losing their identity
Clearly planning for the move to full-time training well in advance, signings like Hardy from Coventry and goalkeeper Naoisha McAloon from Peamont United will form the foundations of the club in years to come. With so much movement expected over the summer, making predictions for next season would be a pointless task, but this season made it clear that the club needed to go full-time to keep up with the Aggie Beevor-Joneses.
And so, adulthood awaits for UK women’s football’s golden child. They are going full-time and sooner or later will be forced to shed their identity as the plucky underdogs. Some disappointing performances on the pitch this season were outweighed by the positives off it, with the club’s fanbase, reputation and identity continuing to flourish. The regression can be largely blamed on improvements elsewhere in the league, but that excuse has now flown out of the window and down the M1.
I hope that when most of us look back at this season in a decade, we will remember the United draw, the Tyne-Wear derby win on the penultimate day, or the Watford comeback. If the move to fulltime training goes as hoped and leads to professionalism and the resumption of the Sanders law of perpetual upwards motion, then it will be remembered as a teenage blip in a glorious rise to the top.
If the move goes awry, then this could become the norm for Durham Women – a mid-table Championship side swaying between false hope of promotion and inevitable relegation scares. For a side who have built their identity as the continually improving underdog, as the model for both economic and on-field efficiency, this would be catastrophic.
Anyone who’s been through it (and I have it on good authority that that’s most of us) will tell you that the transition to adulthood is never easy, and the Golden Child rarely becomes the Consummate Adult. With their toes over the precipice of this monumental change, the Wildcats must keep their balance or risk losing their identity.
Image: Durham Women FC

