How Cricket Scotland’s racism problem highlights an issue that plagues the entire country
By Sanjay Suri
On 25th July 2022, an independent review determined that Scottish Cricket was institutionally racist. This led to the resignation of the entire Cricket Scotland board, and yet another stain on the reputation of cricket in the United Kingdom.
The numbers themselves tell the story. The review found 448 cases of institutional racism, 31 allegations of racism against 15 people and 62% of responders to the survey saying that they had experienced or seen incidents of racism.
This report comes just one year after Yorkshire Cricket Club was also found to be institutionally racist, following allegations made by former England Under 19 captain Azeem Rafiq. Whilst cricket is significantly less popular in Scotland compared to England, it is still a growing sport, and this announcement could well stunt its growth.
2021 was a very successful year on the cricket pitch for Scotland. They reached the ‘Super 12’ stage of the T20 World Cup, securing a landmark win over Bangladesh in the process. Whilst they failed to win a Super 12 match, a narrow loss against eventual finalists New Zealand caught people’s attention, especially amongst Scots getting into the sport.
However, whilst they took one step forward here, the off-field issues represent many steps backwards. Cricket Scotland was found to fail all tests of institutional racism. This news will no doubt discourage those from ethnic minorities from getting into cricket. How can a sport grow when people cannot have trust in the board?
Cricket Scotland was found to fail all tests of institutional racism
It is highly likely that this report has only uncovered the surface of Cricket Scotland’s racism problem. When Yorkshire Cricket came under investigation for institutional racism, stories from across the country started to come out, showing that this was far from an isolated case. Nearly every county had an allegation against them.
Former England captain Michael Vaughan was also forced to step down from TMS after accusations made by Rafiq and three other players that he made racist comments towards them. Vaughan “categorically denies” making these comments but has apologised to Rafiq for any hurt caused.
There are so many examples of incidents like this in British cricket, and serious action is very rarely taken to ensure that it does not happen again.
Cricket Scotland has been instructed to appoint a new board by September; one that is at least 40% male, 40% female and 25% coming from ethnic minority groups. Whilst the latter quota is a step in the right direction, it has echoes of South Africa’s post-apartheid ‘quota system’.
Although this has greatly increased diversity in South African sport, it also has led to players being unfairly targeted, with media often blaming ‘quota players’ for the failure of the team. Furthermore, this system was more suitable in South Africa, where the white population was a significant minority, compared to Scotland, where 96% of the population is white.
What has happened in Scotland is no exception and is seen across the UK
This review on Cricket Scotland has made one thing clear: racism in British cricket is still very much an issue. It affects all levels of cricket. Every single member of England’s Test squad to face India in July was white. Yorkshire Cricket Club, one of the most famous cricketing counties in England, is institutionally racist.
Even at a grassroots level, discrimination can be seen. Even at Team Durham, the culture is poor and extends to cricket. Cricket has a reputation of being a ‘Private School Sport’, and Team Durham is no different, as was investigated by Palatinate two months ago. The diversity in DUCC, especially in the higher teams, does not represent the diversity of the country or the university itself.
So, what is the solution? Whilst quick changes, as seen in Cricket Scotland, are positive, an overall change in culture is needed. The report has recognised an institutionally racist organisation, and those who were most responsible are no longer in charge. The new board faces an important challenge in making sure that progress continues to be made. Institutional racism has stalled the progress of cricket in Scotland, ruined the careers of many players and is discouraging young people from taking up the sport. What has happened in Scotland is no exception and is seen across the UK. A culture change is needed in order to remove the stain on the reputation of cricket.
Image: Paul Hudson via Flickr

