Cherry picking of the Liberal International Order 

By Beatrice Rich

On January 3rd, the US government dramatically kicked off the new year with Operation Absolute Resolve: a military incursion resulting in the capture of Venezuela’s President Maduro from a fortified base in the country’s capital, Caracas. The use of military action to force a serving president into incarceration has of course attracted widespread attention from the international community, sparking reactions of both condemnation and fervent support from prominent world leaders. 

The Trump Administration’s latest international actions raise important questions regarding the status of the liberal international order: was the operation warranted under the global rule-of-law? Can the US still position itself as a convener of liberal peace? And if not, what is the future of the countries and organisations seeking to uphold the norms of international governance?  In order to understand the significance and possible implications of this operation, it is first necessary examine the circumstances which have led to this extraordinary use of force on foreign soil. 

Trump’s opposition to the Venezuelan regime dates to 2019, when Nicolás Maduro was made President following the withdrawal of the country’s constitution and a fraudulent election. The US position on Venezuela at this time was not unique: numerous states, including Canada, Chile, and the EU collectively, refused to recognise Maduro as a legitimate leader. What distinguished the US approach was the decision to escalate charges against Maduro to a New York district court in 2020; senior officials in the Venezuelan government were indicted for narco-terrorism and numerous arms offences, with the regime accused of financing international drug smuggling networks. This legal background has underpinned Trump’s approach to Venezuela throughout his second term, with the US President attacking Maduro’s regime as a “foreign terrorist organisation” on Truth Social in December 2025. In framing the Venezuelan government as a facilitator of organised crime across the Western Hemisphere, the US administration has formulated its primary justification for the use of force in Operation Absolute Resolve. 

The safety of numerous international alliances is now reliant on one man’s determination to put ‘America First’

While critics of the intervention have questioned the legality of US actions, the domestic consequences of Maduro’s authoritarianism similarly demand attention. Venezuela has experienced widespread humanitarian crisis because of corrupt leadership and poor resource distribution; economic stability across the country has plummeted in recent years, leading to inflation rates of 270% according to European Humanitarian Aid Operations, with a 70% reduction in healthcare provision and poor access to basic amenities of electricity and clean water. In the immediate aftermath of US intervention, leaders reluctant to emphatically condemn the US have highlighted this dynamic in their analyses. Prime Minister Keir Starmer, for example, stated that the UK will “shed no tears” at the end of Maduro’s regime, recognising that the deposition of the leader is a positive step for Venezuela’s development potential. This sympathy with the domestic situation has not, however, translated into widespread support for US government actions. Consensus within the liberal international community has instead expressed concern at the flagrant display of military power which is largely at odds with the global rule-of-law. 

Since its introduction in 1945, the UN Charter has emphasised that a nation must refrain from the use of force against another state except in circumstances of self-defence or explicit Security Council authorisation. Critics of US actions in Venezuela have argued that the capture of Maduro contradicts the terms of the Charter, emphasising the absence of an armed attack against the US by Venezuelan forces, and the lack of Security Council insight. The Trump administration maintains that Venezuela’s role in the exportation of cocaine and fentanyl poses a direct physical threat to US citizens; however, last week’s announcement of $2 billion cuts in federal spending towards mental health and addiction prevention services suggest that the domestic drug problem is not a central priority for the current government. Prominent political commentators, like think-tank Chatham House, have therefore concluded that legal justifications for US actions “are hard to see,” arguing that equating narco-terrorism with an armed attack simply does not meet the UN’s definition of self-defence. 

Despite American representatives assuming a central role in writing and enforcing the UN Charter, this is not exactly the first time that a US President has breached international law. President George W. Bush’s highly controversial invasion of Iraq in 2003, President Obama’s Libya intervention in 2011, and US strikes in Syria in 2017, are all examples of the US acting beyond the authority of the Security Council. What is concerning about President Trump’s actions in Venezuela specifically is his open disdain not just for the terms of the UN Charter, but the existence of the organisation itself. Military action in Latin America and the Trump administration’s recent threats to Denmark’s sovereignty in Greenland have the potential to seriously upset the balance of the international order. US engagement with both territories clearly extends beyond security concerns, reflecting a broader desire for control over their vast preserves of natural resources. With Venezuela in possession of the world’s largest oil reserves, and Greenland sitting above largely untapped deposits of oil, natural gas, and valuable minerals, the safety of numerous international alliances is now reliant on one man’s determination to put ‘America First’. The next few weeks will be crucial in assessing the severity of Trump’s threats to take the Danish territory by force, with the diplomatic negotiating power of the EU and deterrent status of NATO being put to the ultimate test.

Image: The White House via Wikimedia Commons