Death Row Under Fire 

By Beatrice Rich

A botched execution and a sentence to death by firing squad: what federal executions tell us about Trump. 

Earlier this month, the US Department of Justice announced that it would be carrying out its first military execution in 60 years. If this was not spectacle enough, the Trump administration added a further startling twist: the whole event would be livestreamed across the internet to swathes of morbidly curious spectators. 

The target of these plans, Nidal Hasan, is the perpetrator of a 2009 mass shooting at the Fort Hood military base in Texas. The attack killed 13 unarmed US military personnel and injured a further 32; his punishment, death by firing squad, has been described by the US Secretary of Defence as one befitting his crimes. 

Alongside the staggeringly botched execution of Christa Pike in September, this announcement has plunged capital punishment into the centre of international controversy. The reemergence of firing squads as a legitimate means of execution, and the failure of not one, but two doses of lethal injection to successfully end Pike’s life, calls into question the morality, and indeed the necessity, of the death penalty in modern America. What place do state authorised killings have in 2026? And what lessons can we learn about the Trump administration in their endorsements of such practice? 

The US is one of around 50 countries that retains the death penalty as a punishment for violent crime. It sits in this category alongside China, Iran, Afghanistan, and Saudi Arabia, with only Afghanistan and Iran carrying out executions publicly. 1,695 men and women have been executed by the US government since the 1970s; however, a moratorium on capital punishment introduced under President Biden saw a temporary suspension in federal executions.  

Capital punishment was reintroduced by President Trump on the first day of his second term, with a rapid escalation in federal executions over the past 18 months. The cases of Pike and Hasan represent an increasingly hardline stance on the use of execution by the current US government, with the Justice Department expanding methods beyond lethal injection, approving the use of firing squads, gas asphyxiation, and electrocution. 

Trump himself declared on Truth Social that the public execution of Hasan would act as “a strong deterrent,” for potential criminals, with the livestream allowing “the world to witness how America deals with terrorists and SCUM.” This sentiment is strongly challenged by human rights organisations, whose research has exposed that the death penalty fails to deter future crime and instead operates as a weapon of state control. 

The Christa Pike case exposes another short falling in the use of capital punishment: it does not always work. Pike was subjected to two doses of lethal injection, after the first failed to end her life; when the second injection also failed, she was hospitalised and received treatment to reverse the effects of pentobarbital. As the only woman on Death Row in the state of Tennessee, Pike has been imprisoned since 1996 for the brutal murder of 19-year-old classmate Colleen Slemmer. 

While she undoubtedly deserves a lengthy sentence for such a horrific crime, Pike becomes the 65th victim of a botched execution over the last 50 years in the US (although her survival of the lethal injection is said to be ‘unprecedented’). With protections against “cruel and unusual punishment” afforded by the 8th Amendment of the US Constitution, just how wrong must an execution go before it becomes cruel? 

With protections against “cruel and unusual punishment” afforded by the 8th Amendment of the US Constitution, just how wrong must an execution go before it becomes cruel? 

Prominent figures within US politics have been quick to weigh in on the death penalty debate. Democratic Senator Chris Murphy likened the administration’s plans to livestream the Hasan execution to systematic killings carried out by Islamic State. Vice President, JD Vance, also shared his reservations, stating that if this execution was to be streamed, he would not be tuning in. This apparent split within the Trump camp has led to a surprising government U-turn: the execution will no longer be broadcast, but the archaically “eye for an eye” presence of the firing squad looms large in Nidal Hasan’s imminent future. 

The decision of the Department of Justice to call off the livestream is not at all reassuring. Escalating numbers of executions, the brutality of a death by firing squad, and the sickeningly torturous endurance of two doses of pentobarbital suggests that this administration is not afraid to use capital punishment as a tool of fear. Broadcasting executions to dark corners of the internet is no longer a practice exclusive to clandestine terror cells, but remains a very real possibility for the United States government. 

Aligning their stance on capital punishment with that of authoritarian, ‘enemy’ regimes reveals a great deal about the Trump administration: gone are the days of subtle attempts to undermine democratic values, and in their place emerges a much more blatant disregard for the norms of liberal governance. Should the next administration, whomever they may be, wish to break from Trump’s government, they should join the 113 countries that refuse to engage in this cruel and unusual punishment. 

Image credit: Wikimedia commons/Ali Shaker/VOA