Are the UK’s falling birth rates a political issue? Analysing Goodwin’s fertility statements

By Beatrice Rich

The Gorton and Denton by-election, held on 26 February, marked a significant development in British politics. The underperformance of the Conservative Party and Labour’s loss of a parliamentary seat suggest declining support for the country’s two main parties, with an electoral competition increasingly emerging between the Green Party and Reform UK. In this instance, Hannah Spencer of the Green Party secured victory, providing a valuable foothold for the Greens in the evolving rivalry between Zack Polanski’s progressive left and Nigel Farage’s nationalist right.

During the race for the seat Gorton and Denton, statement’s made by Reforms running candidate, Matt Goodwin, resurfaced. In 2024, Goodwin expressed concern over what he deemed an ongoing “fertility crisis”, stating that many women were having children “much too late in life”. Resultingly, he proposed an economic incentive to tackle the falling birth rate. This involved scrapping income tax for women with two or more children, while implementing a negative child benefit tax for those without.

Goodwin’s comments have been met with backlash from within parliament, the public, and various women’s right groups. With Bolsover MP, Natalie Fleet, comparing Goodwins statements to a “Handmaid’s Tale Future”.

In 2024, Goodwin expressed concern over what he deemed an ongoing “fertility crisis”, stating that many women were having children “much too late in life”

Despite the controversial nature of Goodwin’s comments, he is not the sole representative within Reform UK to confront this so-called “crisis”. Danny Kruger, formerly a Conservative MP who joined Nigel Farage’s party in September 2025, expressed concern about what he described as Britain’s “totally unregulated sexual economy.”. He observed that marriage no longer plays a central role in shaping national sexual behaviour, suggesting the United Kingdom should reaffirm its traditional family structures. The party advocates for the values of “family, community, country,” which support conventional views of the family unit and reflect its broader opposition to progressive social policies.

While the solutions to the falling birth rate provided by Matt Goodwin are not amongst the policies proposed by Reform, this underlying anti-feminist discourse poses a very real threat to women who have chosen to abstain from motherhood.

The party advocates for the values of “family, community, country,” which support conventional views of the family unit and reflect its broader opposition to progressive social policies

Reform’s combination of conservative rhetoric alongside the proposed reduction of legislative protections, such as repealing the 2010 Equality Act, provides insight into the leadership’s views regarding the appropriate expression of gender roles.  

Hannah Spencer’s win offers some encouragement to the progressive left ahead of the May elections, though the picture remains uncertain. With Reform UK continuing to poll strongly, the party is well-positioned to make significant gains. This prospect, together with Goodwin’s comments, highlights the evolving dynamics of contemporary British politics and the range of potential outcomes that remain.

Image: January via Wikimedia Commons