Cake couture

Cupcakes are in. Lydia Ashby considers why it is definitely quality, not quantity, that matters.

No longer are cupcakes confined to the sticky realms of children’s parties. Ever since Carrie from Sex and the City was filmed tucking into a thickly butter-creamed cake, they have exploded in popularity. The rich and famous are particular fans (perhaps because they are among the few happy to pay the extortionate price of £1.75 per cupcake).

From Victoria Beckham to Madonna, the celebrity world orders mountains of cupcakes for weddings and birthdays (although I wonder who’s actually eating them.) Google recently revealed that ‘cupcakes’ is the fastest rising recipe search in the UK, showing that the cupcake obsession is becoming an endemic across the country. Those not willing to buy the beautiful, artisan cupcakes produced by establishments such as Primrose Bakery are having a shot themselves. In short the cupcake industry is booming.

Whilst researching for this article, I stumbled across a website providing ‘cupcake couture’, enabling those who so desired to ‘dress up’ their cupcakes. One particular bun was sporting a little paper jacket, very much like the jackets that some dog owners make their pets wear. Now, even I, as an ardent admirer of the humble cupcake, was shocked to see how much cupcake fever is veering out of control. A cupcake needs a paper jacket as much as dogs with natural fur coats need a knitted jumper. Oh dear.

But what is behind this cupcake craze?  Perhaps it’s because there is no beleaguered sense of duty to share a cupcake with anyone. There’s no need to squabble over who gets the most icing. And there’s the added bonus that as cake eating goes, it is relatively guilt free, meaning, in the words of Little Britain’s Marjorie Dawes, “half the calories so you can eat twice as much.” Seems good to me.

Cupcake connoisseurs have long debated the difference between fairy cakes and cupcakes. As far as I can see, the only characteristic that tells them apart is that fairy cakes have domed tops, whereas cupcakes are flat. Personal preference dictates which one people opt for-I am a stickler for lots of icing, so I choose cupcakes every time.

Distressingly, there is a very limited supply of cupcakes within Durham. After hours of tasting, (all in the name of research) there were very few places which sell cupcakes to the high standard which is now usually so easy to find. Whilst Brown Sugar and Greggs made a good attempt, it wasn’t enough. A proper cupcake should have delicious sponge, packed with flavour. The icing should be sweet and creamy, with the correct proportion of icing to sponge. Finally, a truly excellent cupcake should look seductively good enough to eat. The reason why cupcakes are a common subject for birthday cards and postcards is because they look pretty. Crystallised flowers, sugar craft and sprinkles are all vital for the full effect. The disappointing lack of the perfect cupcake in Durham leads me to suggest only one thing: make your own. Even the most domestically challenged can whip up a culinary masterpiece of a cupcake. Here’s how:

Basic Cupcake Recipe
(Makes 12)

For the cake:

  • 4oz/115g butter, at room temperature
  • 4oz/115g caster sugar
  • 2 eggs, lightly beaten
  • Half teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 4oz/115g self-raising flour
  • 2 tablespoons milk

For the icing:

  • 11oz/300g cream cheese
  • 2oz/60g butter, at room temperature

or

  • 13oz/360g butter, at room temperature
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 12oz/340g icing sugar
  1. Preheat oven to 180 C/350 F/Gas Mark 4. Line a muffin tin with cupcake cases (the tin helps support the cupcakes during cooking).
  2. Beat the butter with electric mixers or a wooden spoon until creamy. (If using a spoon, be prepared, it will take about 10 minutes, but it’s worth it!)
  3. Add the sugar and beat again until pale and fluffy.
  4. Add the eggs, a little at a time, and beat well in between each addition, ensuring everything is fully mixed up.
  5. Beat in the milk and vanilla extract.
  6. Fold in the flour.
  7. Blob the mixture into the cupcake cases. Only fill up two thirds of the case because they rise. Bake for 15-20 minutes, or until golden and springy to the touch. Cool.
  8. Beat the butter and cream cheese (if using) with the vanilla extract until soft, then slowly add the icing sugar. (Don’t add the icing sugar all at once otherwise you’ll create a mushroom cloud of sugar which will go everywhere but in the bowl). Chill for 15 minutes before spreading onto the cooled cupcakes.

There is no excuse for a bland cupcake. Let your imagination run wild: bring on the carrot, lemon drizzle, chocolate fudge, gingerbread or orange. Any cake recipe will do, just divide the mixture into cupcake cases (don’t fill them too full) and bake for 15-20 minutes. Similarly, substitute the vanilla extract in the icing for grated lemon or orange zest, cocoa powder, coffee essence or rose water. To make butterfly cupcakes, cut out a hole in the top of the cupcake and fill with icing, then cut the top in half and arrange to look like butterfly wings. Use crystallised flowers or edible sugar decorations to add the finishing touches.

If you can’t be bothered to have a go at making your own, shame on you. Nevertheless, a very convincing cheat/alternative is to buy ready made cupcakes (Tesco Express on North Road sell them). These can then be iced with as much artistic flair as you can conjour, and will turn any unsuspecting person into a Nigella-esque domestic goddess. Cupcakes can be made with such ease it’s no wonder a cupcake craze is spreading.