Body positivity isn’t just a plus sized issue
By Helen Spalding
Facebook banned a photo of plus-sized model Tess Holliday, posing in a bikini for a body positivity event, for violating its ad regulations in May 2016. Facebook gave the following as the reason: “Ads may not depict a state of health or body weight as being perfect or extremely undesirable” and “ads like these are not allowed since they make viewers feel bad about themselves.”
Facebook’s reasoning, reasoning since withdrawn with apologies due to the backlash over their decision, is quite interesting when removed from the specifics of the Holliday context. Facebook seems here to be both preventing an ideal of perfection being pressed upon its audiences, as well as preventing body-shaming from its audience of specific body types.
One can see the damage in allowing ads and campaigns to use unhealthy body sizes for promotion as it creates a dangerous concept of perfection. France’s ruling that models now must present a medical certificate declaring them medically fit to work, and restricting the digital alteration of photos, tackles the other end of the eating spectrum, preventing an unhealthily thin body type being the means of fashion and beauty promotions.
A key difference in the treatment of undersize and oversize models however is that the 21st Century image of female beauty is not oversize, but thin. Studies have proven that the tall, lean, thin body type that models until more recently strove to present is natural in less than 1% of the world’s women. Examples of the pressure on models to emulate this thin ideal is everywhere in the fashion world, Erin Heatherton leaving Victoria’s Secret earlier this year due to pressure to lose weight is just one recent instance. On every high street shop’s wall, in every yoghurt advert, in the dolls that girls play with, thin is what is sold as desirable.
The other end of the spectrum, the plus-sized end, while also an unhealthy body type, cannot create through ads and campaigns the same positive, leading image of being overweight. What is more, the plus-sized ranges they sell and body positivity campaigns are specifically targeting a bracket that is also plus-sized, whereas models (not all of whom are underweight, but who are a representation of the slimmer beauty image society prescribes to) are selling an image to anyone who does not fall within that plus-sized bracket.
This binary, thin or ‘not thin’, is what is so damaging because it naturally creates the very landscape that Facebook is hoping to manually prevent – one where a specific body type is presented as perfection, and by proxy, all others deemed undesirable. What about the sizes in between 0 and 16? Where is their representation? Their celebration in the media?
The sporting body type does not fall into the thin, desirable category, and while not being classed as plus-sized, are therefore unattractive. Look at the comments female athletes receive regarding their appearances. The body shaming and negative press Rebecca Adlington, Olympic gold medal winner, received caused a break-down over her body image whilst on I’m a Celebrity… Get Me Out of Here. This year, during Wimbledon, New York Times reporter Ben Rothenberg focused his article about body image among elite female athletes on Serena Williams’ “large biceps and a mold-breaking muscular frame” and why that body type is undesirable to other athletes.
Dascha Polanco, Orange is the New Black star, revealed in a recent Vogue article that designers won’t dress her for the red carpet because of an “underlying sense of ‘size-ism’”. She is a size 8-10, and an unwillingness and inability to dress her stems from the fact that this is too large a body type for high end fashion despite being healthy and active. Amy Schumer was classed as plus sized on the cover of Glamour magazine despite being a size 6-8, and the American plus sized being size 16 and over. She said to Jimmy Fallon regarding the issue, “We don’t need these labels. We don’t need them. It should just say what size you are, right? Why?”
Body positivity is not solely a plus sized issue, it is a result of the binary lens we view the female body in. Thin or ‘not thin’, the ‘not thin’ (as in the case of Schumer and Glamour) often falling into plus sized despite that not actually being plus sized. It is important that we see a diversity in advertising and media of body size, a diversity more reflective of the diversity of shapes and sizes in reality. The removal of an exclusive body ideal in favour of representative variety allows for body positivity at the source rather than as a consolation.
If any ideal should be projected for female beauty it should be health, fitness and strength in whatever form they manifest – characteristics seemingly still not valued in the feminine aesthetic (as in the case of Williams and Adlington). The reason I highlight these characteristics is because they point to more than body as an object of admiration and beauty, but indicative of capabilities and functions beyond the purely aesthetic. It is about time women stopped being solely evaluated on the basis of their bodily appearance.
Photograph: Alan Cleaver via Flickr
