Elitist and pretentious, Team Durham is screwing us over
By Stuart Flegg
Sport should be for the many, not the few. Team Durham has its priorities wrong; exceptional people don’t matter.
Durham University is just that, a University. Quite understandably we all get rather cross when it tries to be anything else. You only need to look at the outrage over the exorbitant spending to furnish the Palatine with art to get the point. Only there is a problem, that’s not the point. Being a university gives at least something of a mandate to support weird art and weirder architecture. It could conceivably come under the umbrella of ‘centre for learning’. There is however one thing that certainly does not: running round and catching balls. In a word: sport. Sport is expensive, sports centres are expensive. It’s about time we had a look at whether it’s actually worth it.
Team Durham has a mission, a pretentious mission statement: ‘allowing exceptional people to do exceptional things’. That is the first half of it. In my mind at least it goes on to read ‘and screwing everyone else’ because anyone who has tried to engage with the management of this group will tell you that nobody else is allowed to do anything. I can imagine the committee of consultants meeting:
“Enabling? Helping?” That is clearly what it means, they will make it possible for the exceptional things to happen.
“We should go for ‘allowing’, the others make it seem like we’re part of the success. It’s the success of the exceptional individual, we just let it happen”
I’m not saying we shouldn’t do sport at universities, we should. Healthy body, healthy mind and all that. The healthy mind bit is important though; you should be here to get a degree. If you’re not, then why are you here?
One of the criticisms levelled at the art spending is that some of it is hidden away. Yes you can take a tour to see it, but that’s a hasty bolt on at best. It is not there for everyone, its elitist. Hidden away, it won’t be bettering anyone’s soul expect for the VC’s PA. Team Durham has precisely the same problem.
All the resources, training and facilities are spent on a select few. If you happen to be one of the two or so hundred, congratulations. You’ve managed to screw over everyone else. We’re paying for your star treatment.
I honestly find this baffling. What’s it for? It’s not for the ‘regular student’. If you believe the spin, good performance in the BUCS league will bring promotion and prestige to the University. Maybe it does, but this just raises more questions. Durham is a great academic institution. Since when did we need to rely on the sport tables to recruit enough students? More importantly, what could we even offer to these great sportspeople that could ever compete with international level training schemes? The way they hamper on about ‘our Olympians’ you would think we were one of those, not a university.
Secondly on recruitment, BUCS points are extremely transient as a currency of worth. Yay, we’re Britain’s second greatest sporting university! Look at all our BUCS points. And … they’re gone. It’s September again and we’re back on nul points, only in the top half of the table on account of ‘D’ being fourth in the alphabet.
It might have been expensive, but at least the Picasso is still here. If we fall on hard times we could actually sell the Warhol soup prints.
You should be angry about this. All of it. I know what you might be feeling. You like sport, you like nice facilities and you even got to use the rubber crumb one time when they let you play for the college Bs. That doesn’t mean it’s your facility. You pay for that. Several times. Through your university membership and then again through your team or JCR. Team Durham bill you for the privilege of playing on those facilities you paid for. To them we are all just the equivalent of those uninspired middle aged couples who would place their caravan on the school fields during summer. We’re a revenue stream.
That priority is horrendously wrong. University sport should be about engaging everyone. The college system does this so well. It’s about friendship and team spirit. It’s about staying active and healthy. It’s not about national tables. It is only about winning when that’s the fun. Fun. As in Collingwood D versus Mildert C.
Worst of all, this is totally unnecessary. What do you think has brought more joy? What’s brought a better experience to the most people: The million pound rowing tank or the scrubby patch of dirt off South Road? I’ll give you a clue, it’s not the first one.
This focus on big winners doesn’t represent the rest of us. It really shouldn’t be anyone’s justification for coming here either. If you are really at that level of sporting exception, don’t come to a university. You’ll have to waste time with a pesky degree. But if you absolutely must have one but you also want something topping the BUCS table, then you should really apply to Loughborough. After all they came in first.
Photograph: Team Durham
