Homegrown’s cancellation challenges how free our speech really is

Gun typewriter landscape (Mariam Hayat)

By Helen Spalding

The National Youth Theatre (NYT)’s production of Homegrown, playwright Omar El-Khairy’s controversial play exploring the motives behind the radicalization of young people joining the Islamic State, was cancelled just weeks before its opening night. In an interview with The Guardian, director Nadia Latif hypothesizes that this must have been due to “extraordinary external pressure”. Latif feels her attempt to see “an intelligent conversation around an issue that has hysteria attached” has been silenced through its cancellation, a notion cast member Qasim Mahmood echoes in a tweet on July 31: “Censored. Our voices were silenced today.”

Previous cases of unofficial censorship of theatre in the UK have mainly been for the safety and protection of cast and crew. An example would be the cancellation of Gurpreet Kaur Bhatti’s play Behzti in 2004, whose rape scene in a Sikh temple caused protests so violent Bhatti went into hiding for her own life.

Though perhaps safety was a consideration, the reasons for the cancellation of Homegrown were not as obvious as this. As early as June, it had already been forced to move venue due to its controversial content, and the reason finally given for its cancellation by Paul Roseby, Artistic Director of NYT, was “to prevent any damage to NYT’s reputation and membership”. One can only speculate over the specifics of the “extraordinary” pressure behind this decision, given the lack of official comment from parties applying it. However, it is likely that the local authorities’ fear that too great an insight into radicalization might inspire further extremism may have played a role.

The fear of inspiration of extremism in young people by depicting its effects in a play completely underestimates and patronizes audiences of today.

Whilst the play in question is not extremist propaganda, the greatest issue I had in writing this article was that in arguing freedom of speech, one also permits the expression of extremist beliefs and opinions and allows them space on the stage or in the public eye, giving them the potential to dangerously influence the public. However, what renders such propaganda and extremism ineffective is not its removal, but the allowance of contradictions, alternating perspectives and arguments.

Dictatorships in Russia, Germany and China during the 20th Century censored arts and press mercilessly. McCarthyism in the 1950s saw strict artistic and political censorship in the ‘Land of the Free’ to create a Cold War, anti-communist mentality amongst people. Extremism only becomes held as gospel truth in the absence of contradicting responses and arguments.

The fear of inspiration of extremism in young people by depicting its effects in a play completely underestimates and patronizes audiences of today. The internet, news and theatre itself provide us with a myriad of perspectives and insights into areas outside of our spheres of experience and understanding. The advancement of technology, freedom of speech and democratic society all seem to aim to develop a society of thinkers. The very concept of censorship is a regression from all that has been achieved.

With its immediacy and potency, theatre provides human insight, perhaps more than any other medium. It is focused on the exploration of the private and the hidden through behaviour and character. Theatre moves audiences simply by presenting raw interaction, conversation and personality and is a humanizing and open-minded means of expression for this reason. It allows for an honesty of experience. Perhaps this is what Kathleen Turner, American film and stage actor, means by describing theatre as an “extraordinary communication between people”.

Removing it from the stage does not remove it from the corridors of schools where radicalization continues to be an issue.

Homegrown, rather than being the promotion of any particular argument or mindset, aimed to create a mirror of the effects of extremism and radicalization on young people within a play and a recreation of the reality in schools. Developed through workshops with young actors, the play aimed to reflect the existing mindset. It hoped to be a totally immersive experience, set in a school, where the audience wanders through scenes performed by the huge cast of 112 youths (all aged between 15 and 25), experiencing this reality for themselves.

Homegrown strove to offer insight rather than opinion. Its content merely demonstrates existing, real-life circumstances, and removing it from the stage does not remove it from the corridors of schools where radicalization continues to be an issue. Its censorship contributes to a continuing social ignorance and racism that already creates a breeding ground for extremism in all forms.

viewpoPeople have both a right to express their perspective and to an awareness of the perspectives of others. The removal of such expression from the public eye merely creates a far greater danger of a form of propaganda via absence – the shaping of the public’s opinion by an incomplete image of events and views. Expression of extremist opinion through art is dangerous, but more so is the lack of discussion and expression of certain viewpoints and perspectives.

Illustration: Mariam Hayat