Autumn Internationals: Eddie Jones’s chance to regain fans’ confidence?
By Max Malone
England Men’s Rugby’s disappointing performances in the last two Six Nations have left fans and pundits questioning Eddie Jones’s leadership of the side. The clashes with Argentina, Japan, New Zealand, and South Africa present a golden opportunity for Eddie’s Army to show strength as a World Cup year approaches.
Assessing England’s chances in order, Argentina may be the easiest game of the bunch. While Michael Cheka’s leadership has brought Los Pumas an impressive series victory over an admittedly understrength Scotland in the summer tour – as well as some strong performances in the Rugby Championship – they have yet to develop the staying power to deflect a determined opposition in the second half.
Although many Argentine forwards – like Leicester’s Julian Montoya – have proved their defensive worth, the flair of Marcus Smith faced with a broken field looks to be too much for a side prone to gassing out in the final 20 minutes. Although, 60 minutes may be optimistic if England exploit Argentina’s habit of committing two men to big tackles to keep them under constant pressure.
However, the Pumas have claws in attack. Players like winger Matteo Carreras are not to be underestimated, especially after scoring a blistering try from his own 22 for Newcastle against Northampton. In any case, this will be a match worth watching.
The clashes present a golden opportunity for Eddie’s Army to show strength as a World Cup year approaches
In a similar category would be Japan. By all indications, the Brave Blossoms have their biggest game of the season against New Zealand two weeks before they play England, as they aim to make history by beating them – as Ireland did this summer.
This is not to say that a walkover against a tired team is a foregone conclusion. Japan’s kicking game – a historical weakness in their attack – has come leaps and bounds over the past two World Cup cycles, thus making their intricately structured offence a potent threat. However, if England can use their larger forwards to dominate at the breakdown, scrums, and lineouts then they should carry the day.
On to one of the two marquee matches to end the series: the All Blacks. The Kiwis have somewhat bounced back from their battering at the hands of the Irish this summer, narrowly winning the Rugby Championship. The introduction of Joe Schmitt to their coaching team has brought a semblance of a greater strategy to their attack rather than leaning on the crutch of players’ individual brilliance.
Kiwi pundits seem to think that the All Blacks may rest their stars in the Scotland match the week before they play England, meaning that Ian Foster and the men in black are coming for a fight.
Depending on the squad the All Blacks put forward there are several, widely known, vulnerabilities in their defence. An English game-plan focused on targeting George Bower – or other forwards prone to being out of position – on the counterattack could break open the game for them.
They are running uphill with injuries and uncertainty over the squad, but the fact is they can beat all four teams they are playing
The final and most challenging match of the series is against the Springboks. The return of rugby’s Lex Luthor, Rassie Erasmus, from his coaching team ban makes them more dangerous than they have been in the past 3 years.
The main criticism of the World Champions is their lack of innovation since 2019. Other teams have moved on, and the Boks’ momentum-based game is no longer the unstoppable force it once was. With Erasmus’ talents back in the changing room, England will be hard-pressed to prepare for them. However, the game ending the series presents the chance to anticipate what a drained South Africa may put forward.
Much as I am confident in my prediction, of three wins and one loss, it all depends on who Eddie Jones picks on the day – with this being a matter far from resolved. The second factor eating at Eddie’s support – after the results – is the absence of a settled team sheet.
This ‘tournament’ is no different. With a side ravaged by injuries among its stars, and many uncapped players filling the ranks, questions must be raised if an unstable roster can gel quickly enough to deliver results.
While England is – when the wind is right and luck with them – one of the best sides in the world, their ability to capitalise on that in these internationals is unclear. They are running uphill with injuries and uncertainty over the squad, but the fact is they can beat all four teams they are playing. If they will or not depends on the coaches’ ability to find a winning combination. Until the fans find out, in Eddie they will have to trust.
Image: England Kath via Flickr

