Austen: as innocent as she seems?

By Isobel Roser

Darkness is not the first word that springs to mind when considering the literary output of Jane Austen. Her work is often associated with gentility and romance, but rarely with the shadier aspects of life. Perhaps a revision of this long-held view is necessary. While ostensibly Austen’s books are filled with bonnets, ballrooms and bossy mothers, under the surface we can see themes of social injustice and political criticism. From slavery to primogeniture, Austen offers her readers a peek into the darker side of regency high life.

The slave trade is only explicitly mentioned once or twice throughout Mansfield Park, however it maintains a heavy presence throughout the novel. Sir Thomas Bertram, uncle of our heroine Fanny, is understood to be the owner of sugar plantations in Antigua with a workforce of African slaves. Hence the Mansfield Park estate, so central to the characters and plot, was built on the profits of slavery. This fact casts a shadow throughout the novel and resonates deeply within the plot. Austen was writing during a time of highly charged political discussion surrounding slavery, and while she lived to see the abolition of the slave trade, she had died before slaves received full emancipation. Thus her work must be seen within the context of bitter political warfare between abolitionists and plantation owners.

The abolition movement was active in Britain during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, with figures such as William Wilberforce and Granville Sharp championing the cause. It garnered a great deal of popular support, particularly among women of the middle classes. Although we will never know whether Austen formed part of this group, her novels seem to imply a disapproval for slavery. Much like Mansfield Park, Emma seems to depict the author’s sympathy for abolitionism. The movement itself was kick-started by the Somerset Case in 1772, in which Lord Mansfield ruled that while it was legal to keep slaves in the colonies, it was illegal on English soil. Surely it isn’t coincidental that Austen chose to name Fanny’s home, Mansfield Park, after the man who laid the groundwork for the abolition movement.

To the modern reader, some of the darker aspects of Austen’s work lie in her depiction of the social conventions of the day.  We must remember that Austen was a product of her time, so some of the practices in her novels which we view as barbaric and wholly unacceptable, would have been the norm for her. Property forms a key theme in a number of Austen’s novels. In both Pride and Prejudice and Sense and Sensibility, the practice of primogeniture provides a driving force in the plot. Primogeniture asserts the right of the first-born son to inherit the entirety of their parents’ estate. We see this practice in action in Sense and Sensibility, when Mrs Dashwood and her daughters are pushed out of their family home after the death of Mr Dashwood. Austen’s works place the spotlight on the realities of this law, emphasising the darker aspects of the British legal system at this time. Additionally, Pride and Prejudice illustrates the pressure that weighed heavily upon women to consider the monetary implication of their marriage. In many cases, it was vital for women to get married, lest they be unable to support themselves financially. With this in mind, Mrs Bennett’s dogged determination to marry off her daughters seems less ridiculous and more justifiable.

While Austen readily depicts some of the darker aspects of polite society with her trademark acidity and irony, the overall tone generally remains light-hearted. However, in a slight departure from her earlier work, Persuasion offers a sombre, moodier tone, which is worth mentioning when assessing the darker aspects of her novels. In the last of her books, Anne Elliot provides an older, more mature heroine who harbours a great deal of regret and sadness. This contrasts with the girlish optimism of Austen’s other protagonists. Anne’s tendency to look back at the “tenderness of the past” only adds to the gloominess. This mood is captured particularly well by the autumnal refrain, which is scattered throughout the novel. The “autumnal months” provide the perfect backdrop for this melancholic offering from Austen.

Now, we shouldn’t overstate things. Austen can’t be compared to the likes of Mary Shelley or Emily Brontë on the sliding scale of ‘darkness’. Moreover her satirical, light-hearted tone provides a great deal of her charm. Yet the darker aspects of her work are worth a thought. Austen’s novels are often dismissed as simple frivolity – I would heartily disagree with this notion. Subtlety is one of Austen’s greatest weapons in her depiction of the darker aspects of the regency period. Those who claim that she ignores darker topics simply aren’t looking hard enough.

Illustration: Kenzo Ishida