University proposes international students return to Durham for resits

By Jasper Cox

All international students taking resit examinations would have to return to Durham under new proposals undergoing consultation. Currently, international students can request to take resits in their home country.

The Examinations and Assessment Report (EAR) for the 2014/15 examinations cycle mentions various practical problems encountered when students have taken resits overseas.

Among other issues, in Korea and Morocco, the British Council stated they were unable to host exams at the last minute — despite having agreed to do so and having accepted fees from students — who then had to make last-minute plans to return to Durham.

Meanwhile, customs officials in some regions of China impounded packages sent by courier over concerns about the content of the materials. The papers were released just a few hours before the exams started.

According to the EAR, which is available on the University website, requiring all students to take resits in Durham would “would be clear and ensure that all students are treated consistently.”

However, the recommendations do state that students unable to return could apply to their department for a concession. Only two departments disagreed with the idea, though there were concerns about the timing of resits and the availability of college accommodation.

The document proposes that, should resit exams continue to be allowed to be taken overseas, all the resits taken at Durham University should be held at the main campus. Only small numbers currently take resits at Queen’s Campus, which the document claims is an inefficient use of rooms and invigilators and “leads to a poor experience”.

The proposal has been put forward for consultation to Faculty Education Committees. Feedback from each of the Faculty Education Committees will feed into a final report to be presented at the December meeting of Education Committee, who will decide whether or not to approve the recommendations.

Some international students Palatinate spoke to saw some benefits in the proposal. Zoe Destang, a third-year French student, told Palatinate that while this would pose problems for international students, it might represent more of an incentive not to fail exams in the first place.

Bence Baljer, a Hungarian student who studies at Queen’s Campus, said he didn’t think it was “unreasonable” to ask students to come back if they have done badly on an exam, although he didn’t see how it would be that difficult for the University to send exams papers abroad.

However, other students were angrier about the proposal. Sabrina Chong, a third-year Malaysian student, told Palatinate that the financial burden that would be imposed “cannot be justified,” pointing out that international students already pay higher fees than home students.

Were the proposal to be implemented, it would show “the complete disregard” of the University towards international students’ circumstances, and “heighten the disparity between the treatment of and opportunities for home and international students”.

Chong also suggested a potential flaw with the idea, as with the proposed concession system international students could presumably apply to take an exam in their home country on the basis of financial reasons.

She questioned how then the University would then decide who to give concessions for and how it could force students to return to Durham who complained of financial difficulties.

The President of the Malaysian Society, Wai-Fung Teh, told Palatinate that, besides the financial implications, there would also be practical difficulties for students in having to adjust to changes in time zone, climate, and dealing with long-distance travel.

It “would be an unwelcome and unnecessary distraction and hassle” for students who “are expected to be focused on exam preparation”.

Wai-Fung Teh said: “Given the not insignificant tuition fees which international students pay, I feel the University ought to be capable of overcoming the logistical difficulties of administering overseas resits.”

He said “the University is simply passing on the problem to students.”

He commented on the examples given where there have been difficulties, saying the rationale of the proposal seems to be that “if some students are unable to benefit from overseas resits, then no students at all should be allowed to benefit”.

Photograph: David Hawgood via Geograph