Judges on Trial: Have Tabloid Papers Overstepped?

By Isobel Roser

When checking the newspaper headlines on Friday 4th November, you may have been forgiven for thinking that you had woken up in an apocalyptic parallel universe where the will of the British people had been crushed by an over-mighty legal system. Indeed, the Daily Express had the tenacity to claim that the High Court Article 50 ruling was “a crisis as grave as…the dark days when Churchill vowed we would fight them on the beaches”.

This ludicrous overreaction was not merely confined to the Express; the entire right-wing press chose to point an accusatory finger at the judges who presided over the ruling. The Daily Mail and the Telegraph even emblazoned their front pages with mugshot-style images of the judges in question, casting them as villains in their fanciful political pantomime.

Anyone with a basic understanding of British democracy and our unwritten constitution will be aware that the sensationalist press discourse on this issue is completely unfounded. Lord Chief Justice Thomas noted that the ruling was based purely on the “question of law” in complete isolation from any political considerations. It is an irony that the Brexiteers, who campaigned virulently for our country to ‘take back control’ are so horrified by the ruling that now entitles our representative Parliament to considerably more control over the path of our EU exit.

The poisonous press attack that has been levelled against the independent judiciary is worrying to say the least; pitting judges against ‘the people’ is a rhetoric almost beyond ridicule. Senior Bishop Nick Baines has argued that the language being used by the press to undermine the rule of law is “very dangerous” and even reminiscent of fascist dictatorships.

Indeed, anybody questioning the power of the press to influence public opinion need only consider the vitriolic abuse that has been hurled at Gina Miller, who spearheaded the Article 50 legal challenge. By branding Miller as a Brexit saboteur the press have indirectly incited the racist, sexist online trolls, whether they like it or not.

In a political climate which is becoming increasingly polarised, the dogged determination of the right-wing press to stoke the fires of extremism is shameful. The opportunity for a reasoned and rational debate was rejected in favour of attention-grabbing headlines. Branding judges as “enemies of the people” is not only ludicrous, but highly inflammatory rhetoric. Passing this kind of judgment on the judiciary was never a good idea.

 

Image by Rock Cohen via Flickr.