The debate: are students necessary victims of the troubled economy?

YES – by Reuben Kirkham

Few people could have missed the recent student protests. Tory HQ was, perhaps tastefully, redecorated. Prince Charles and Camilla were set upon by an angry mob. The catalyst for these protests was the Coalition’s decision to allow universities to charge up to £9,000 a year and the cuts in the government subsidy of higher education.

The cuts being made by the Coalition extend across the board – only the NHS and the Department for International Development are exempt. Yet the rest of the cuts have attracted very little in the way of protest. Is this because they are unlikely to have a similar level of impact? Or is it simply because the Higher Education sector is more vocal?

How about the cuts to our schools? On average, schools get just over £5,000 per pupil per year – substantially less than what universities receive for their students. The Coalition intend to remove 25% of the schools budget – which means that there will be fewer teachers, larger class sizes and, ultimately, a poorer education provided to students.

A substantial number of students leave the education system unable to read and write effectively. A large portion of students leave without C grades or above in their English and Maths GCSEs. The effect of further diminishing the opportunities of many young people will be costly for wider society. Financially, these people will pay less tax and contribute less to society – some will be forced to become dependent upon the state instead – and we also must not forget the human cost.

The cuts in education are likely to be compounded by the fact that the Coalition is also disproportionately targeting the poorer areas of the country. For instance, Manchester is expected to reduce its number of employees by nearly 20% – directly this represents a cut in nearly every service that the council provides, be it leisure centres and libraries or social housing and social services. The cuts to the public sector will of course mean a significant loss of jobs.

Crime will most likely rise as a consequence of disenfranchising more people from society, together of course with the cuts being made to policing, also at 25%. In fact, the cuts are so deep and damaging that the Institute of Fiscal Studies predicts that by 2014, one million more people will be in poverty compared to now.

The Coalition is also targeting disabled people. As things stand disabled people often get a raw deal. There are plans afoot to slash the mobility and care payments disabled people receive, in effect restricting their liberty – in many cases this will mean that disabled people are confined to their homes. Disabled people, some of whom are very vulnerable, are going to have their liberties restricted even more than they are now.

By contrast, no one is going to be directly harmed by the cuts being made to higher education. Indeed, the two main claims made by protestors, that access will be harmed and that the education provided by the university sector will be harmed, are both non-sequiturs. The “debts” incurred by students, unless they earn over £21,000 a year, might as well be Monopoly money. Even after that, they pay back a proportion of their salary over this threshold – indeed for most people it will act as a tax which they pay until they have repaid the cost of their education. Equally, whilst widening participation is very important, the damage is not going to be caused by the £9,000 fees, but the cuts being made to EMA, schooling and to the working classes in general.

Indeed, it is unlikely that many universities will be able to charge £9,000 tuition fees without substantially improving the education that they provide. The Mathematics department for many modules only entitles its students to lectures – so no interaction between student and teacher. Similar complaints have been made elsewhere: Bristol history students lament being provided largely just “library access and a reading list” and Manchester also saw substantial student complaints. Whilst there are services provided, the truth of the matter is that our universities are massively inefficient when it comes to educating students. The reason for this lies in how they are ran. Most decisions are made by academics, who get to vote upon how much tuition they would like to provide and how they would like to provide it. A lot of expenditure in universities is also very wasteful – Durham,for instance, spent £450,000 on a “web refresh”, and another £500,000 on employment tribunals.

Nearly everyone agrees that there must be cuts up to a certain point. As things stand, everyone, rich and poor, will pay some price as a result of these cuts – though, naturally, the poor will collect most of the misery. Given the damage that the rest of the cuts will inflict on ordinary people, it is far better for society if most of these other cuts were to be reversed, before we consider reversing the cuts to higher education. Indeed, the changes in higher education are comparatively well thought-out.

NO – by Alexandra Bottomer

It is easy to judge students as idle, binge-drinking scum who flounce around university studying a subject which probably has no bearing on how well they can do a job. Students are seen as sofa-surfing, Countdown-watching, late-to-bed-late-to-rise, tax-dodging ingrates. After three years, they swan off into a highly-paid job from where they can look down superciliously on the rest of society.

The flames of this disgust are inevitably fanned by articles in the national media describing, “Mickey Mouse degrees” in subjects such as “Applied Golf Management Studies”, available from the University of Birmingham. Degrees were described as a circus, and then someone discovered that the University of Kent offers a degree in Circus Studies.

Durham hasn’t been spared either. Upon announcing that there would be a new optional module in the BA Education Studies called “Harry Potter and the Age of Illusion”, the “Harry Potter Degree” was ridiculed. Nick Seaton, Chairman of the Campaign for Real Education, was quoted in the national press saying, “It does not merit a course at one of the country’s top universities”.

Even supposedly “safe” academic subjects are being lambasted. The website toptenz.net describes Philosophy as “a fun-time four years, open to stoners, egocentrics and those that love the sound of their own voice, who will finish the course even more confused at what they want to do in life and probably end up working in a convenience store”.

As a student of English Literature, I am perpetually defending my choice of subject. Most often, I am under attack from science students who laugh at my woefully low number of contact hours, and who seem to believe that only those students who are actually researching a cure for cancer are doing a “proper degree”.

So, why, with all of the above in mind, am I arguing that students are not necessary victims of the harsh economic times? The answer is simple. Education is essential, and, education should be universal.
I am not saying that everyone should go to university, far from it. There are many hundreds of brilliant careers which do not require a university degree. An air traffic controller may earn more than £80,000 a year without the need for a degree. And, above all else, you cannot put a price on job satisfaction. There are many jobs which are not highly paid at all, and yet, can be fulfilling for both the individual and the wider community.

Instead, I argue, that everyone should have the right, and by extension, the means to go to university if they want to. This is the very right which is being eroded by the education cuts. The Education Maintenance Allowance is a lifeline for many who attend colleges across the country. The sum, which may total £30 a week, can provide money for books, transport costs, field trips, or any other equipment which could assist a youngster to stay in education.

Without a doubt, the EMA is open to abuse. Tighten the system and cut the waste certainly, but preserve the grants for those who really need them, in order to give them a better opportunity in life.
The NUS is campaigning to prevent fees in Further Education; a branch of the education system often referred to as “adult learning”. There are also cuts planned for ESOL, or to give it its full title of English for Speakers of Other Languages, is essential for many people living in Britain for whom English is not their first language.

And then, we come to university tuition fees. As an arts student, I am disgusted by the cuts to arts funding and, were I in a position where tuition fees were £9,000 a year, I would resent paying up to £130 a lecture.  What on earth is such a monumental amount of cash funding?

The government assures us that if fees were increased, poorer students would continue to be supported, although it is unknown whether it will affect the number of applications from less fortunate backgrounds. Similarly, students from affluent families will be able to afford the tuition fee hike, regardless of how expensive university became. The real crisis becomes apparent in students from families with average incomes. They do not qualify for means-tested assistance, whilst not being well-off enough to ride out the storm regardless of cost.

It is from these middle-income families that future doctors, lawyers, teachers and scientists will be lost. “Aha!” cry the sceptics, “But it is not the families that are paying, but the students themselves, they can still get loans to help them, which they pay back only when they are earning a reasonable amount of money. It will teach them to appreciate their education”.

This is inescapably true, to a point. With increases in inflation severely impacting on the cost of living, the average age of a first-time buyer of a home is 31, and the average deposit on a house is more than £30,000. Add to this £40,000 of university debt, the prospect of recession-related unemployment and pay freezes, pay cuts and redundancies, and the picture for graduates seems a lot less rosy.  Intrepid graduates will move abroad resulting in a so-called “brain-drain”, which in time will affect the economy as businesses see the UK as a decreasingly attractive place to operate and be successful.

Students should pay for their education. They should not, however, be treated as cash cows to be plundered and pillaged. Good graduates are an essential part of the economy and society. By all means, hone the system and cut the waste, but don’t punish those with a genuine desire to learn, or else the country will become an intellectual wasteland, available only to the rich and privileged.