Is the Durham Students’ Union a necessary institution?

The DSU provides useful and necessary services for everyone

Alexandra Bottomer

DSU Brownies: God’s gift to the students of Durham. They melt in your mouth, they are an instant hit of chocolatey goodness, they are conveniently available for that dose of sugary heaven in-between lectures… Add to this the fact that they are made by little elves in the depths of the DSU (or so rumour would have it) and I believe we have reason enough to cry from the rooftops, “yes, the DSU is necessary!” There are, however, a multitude of other reasons why the DSU remains a necessary part of student life, even if they are not all as tasty as chocolate brownies.

Durham’s colleges shape every student’s steps through the bewildering years of undergraduate study. From every fresher’s first day in Durham, the value of the colleges, the encouragement of college spirit and the support provided by the college community are instilled as key parts of Durham University life. The DSU’s services are often barely mentioned beyond a quick introduction from a college DSU Representative or a flying visit to Planet Of Sound (POS) or Revolver in Fresher’s Week. This has cultivated an undeserved feeling of apathy and confusion about the purpose of the DSU and its role in student life.

The DSU forms the backbone of the University’s welfare network. The Student Advice Centre provides welfare and support to students on a multitude of levels. The Advice Centre is many students’ first port of call if they are on ERASMUS schemes, have financial problems, physical or mental health worries or even they are in desperate need of free contraception. The Advice Centre can provide support regarding academic issues and can assist students who may wish to make a complaint to the University about any facet of student life.

There are few students in Durham who move into rented accommodation without having their contract checked by the DSU Accommodation Office first, and even fewer who did not use their helpful and informative website to aid in the daunting task of house-hunting.

After a night out on the town, a taxi home from North Road to Gilesgate or the Hill Colleges can cost the best part of £6, yet, one quick call to the Nightbus and you and your mates can be whisked safely home for the flat-rate fee of £1. This service is run at a financial loss by the DSU and is subsidised by funds made by Kingsgate Bar and Riverside Café, yet it is maintained solely for the welfare of the student body, should they need it.

The Margot Fonteyn Ballroom has recently had £10,000 of new lighting equipment installed, resulting in the DSU having the best sound and light facilities of any venue in Durham.

This is only one facet of a refurbishment programme which is currently sweeping through Dunelm House. Alongside the weekly club nights POS and Revolver, the Jazz Café, the Jibber Jabber Comedy Café, retro quiz nights, Silent Discos, the Freshers’ Ball and Freshers’ Bop are all organised by the DSU for the enjoyment of students.

Alongside this, the welfare provision at these events is second to none. The DSU ensures that student welfare is always of primary concern at events such as POS and Revolver; a team from St John’s Ambulance and fully trained security staff are always on hand to help any students who find themselves in difficulty. This may not be seen as important on the average student night out, however, it becomes a welcome safety net when faced with the alternative: being thrown out of a club in town, cold, friendless, inebriated, disorientated and at the mercy of whoever chooses to scrape you off the pavement.

The DSU has a duty of care to attendees of its events which often leads to it paying for transport to take students home if they are in difficulty, to administer first aid where necessary and to ensure that students are looked after in situations where they are unable to look after themselves.

Whist student welfare is undoubtedly a key principle of the DSU, its functions are much broader than advising students about financial affairs or looking after them if they are drunk on the premises. Discounted newspapers, photocopying and rooms available for hire are all on offer for those who require them (although whether the SAC will be renamed Greg’s Luscious Garden remains to be seen).

The DSU is also the home of DUCK, Purple Radio, Palatinate, Student Community Action and the Team Durham Student Office. The DSU acts a portal for contacting virtually every official student society in Durham and allots £15,000 of funds every year to support its societies.

Even more importantly, the DSU provides a forum which represents the entirety of the student body which can be mobilised to great effect. In the past this has taken the form of widespread campaigning regarding tuition fees; in recent weeks it has been part of an ongoing dialogue between the University, the National Union of Students and the Durham Union Society over the cancellation of the multiculturalism debate.

Ultimately, the DSU is a unifying force for a university which otherwise would be divided into individual colleges and academic departments. It provides the student body with a point of focus, where issues may be raised before the entire student population. It is an organisation run entirely for the benefit and representation of students, without which our societies, social calendars and welfare services would be greatly bereft.

And, if nothing else, it remains Durham’s only student-friendly supplier of truly magnificent chocolate brownies.


Following the DUS debacle, the DSU seems to be a purposeless institution

Daniel Dyson

Does the DSU ever do anything right? The answer these days seems to be a resounding roar of ‘NO!’ in a flood of passion so vehement that clichéd ideas of student political apathy must surely be dead and buried.

Even on a superficial note, the DSU is an utter failure. Just look at it. The building is allegedly supposed to be a corrupted version of the cathedral (in that odd language of architects at least) and, if the rumour is true, was meant to be built out of a concrete that allowed ivy to grow on it so that it blended into the riverbank. How appealing. In a classic case of Durham incompetence, that is obviously not the case. Would it really be such a bad thing then if Dunelm House did what the Castle will one day eventually do, and fall into the river?

The disheartening thing is that it is hard to come rushing to the DSU’s defence. In fairness to the students who endlessly devote their time to it, I am positive that they try their best and they do a lot of good work for both university students and for the local area as a whole.

However, unlike most other universities in which the Student Union represents the voice of the masses, Durham has the distinct advantage of being collegiate. Whilst nobody would (or should) argue that their college is perfect, the facilities and support that they offer, in particular welfare, are excellent and it is hard not to feel that DSU welfare systems, whilst a valuable area for support for some, feel a little redundant when there is so much help on tap from other places.

Politically too, the DSU serves little purpose other than ornamentation. Once we disaffiliate from NUS (which, let’s face it, is looking likely), the services that the DSU offer us in terms of a national voice will become redundant. This could easily be a positive though for Durham as the colleges themselves form natural networks and alliances stronger than that between two random institutions such as the DUS and the NUS.

Again, this collegiate aspect of life cannot be underestimated; it seems foolish to treat Durham as if it was indistinguishable from any other university when this is blatantly not the case. If Durham is as different as it believes it is, it should be treated as such and not adopt a model of ‘government’ for the sake of it, just because it works at other institutions. Besides, views and issues that are relevant to us are better represented on a smaller basis where individual voices can be more clearly heard and reacted to – the sum is made up of its parts after all, and that is what makes Durham great.

This is not even mentioning the fact that the DSU, since the death of the beloved shop, is now essentially a collection of empty rooms, so much wasted space. It is no wonder that the Union has so much debt; dare I ask how it makes its money? It would make a lot more sense for the DSU to rent out the spare rooms to an evil conglomerate or two (Starbucks anybody?) and actually help reverse the deficit cascade we seem to have as a Union instead of plunging blindly into further debt.

Yes, the recession is hitting everybody hard but this refusal to use the space available to us just seems like a case of the DSU staff cutting off their nose to spite their faces. We have had some investment, but compared to other universities up and down the country, our facilities as a Union are woefully inadequate.

Luckily, they are supported by college facilities. Again, these may not be excellent, but I would imagine the average student uses them a damn sight more than any of the ones at the DSU.

The money element of the DSU though is everything. If there is nothing in our Union, then no people will go in. If there is nobody in there, then what little remains struggles and eventually closes and the vicious cycle continues until, like the Titanic, the DSU sinks back into the abyss from which it appears to have been brought from. The DSU is definitely outdated until it thinks of a solid reason why we should go there instead of elsewhere.

The Café for example does serve delicious food and who doesn’t love the legendary chocolate brownies? But considering the average clientele of the students are livers-out or hillfolk who can’t be bothered walking all the way back up to where they live and have a free hour or so, and the amount of other cafes and restaurants in Durham with better décor, and it’s extremely difficult to think of an impetus to go there. Even the bar is usually empty non-event nights. When your Union bar is desolate, then you know there’s something wrong.

Whilst on the social note, Revolver and POS are both excellent, and although Durham’s club scene is a little on the anaemic side to say the least, POS in particular is certainly expensive for what it offers, especially considering a lot of colleges have discounted nights elsewhere. For me personally, POS is a glorified, modern Klute – and yet £5 extra; a lot of money for 3 days difference. It is no wonder, then, that the bar worries so much about bad nights as they cannot afford to lose any profits. They would gain by lowering admission – but can they afford to do that in the first place?

When you think back over your time in Durham, will you remember the Union fondly? Sure, the odd night spent here or there, probably, but chances are your college will scream out at you, rather than the Union and that itself is telling. The DSU is outdated and unnecessary because it is inflexible. Without the ability to try and adapt to an ever-changing student body, it will not recover.