Skydiving for charity will not help the poor
Good intentions can get you far. In the world of charity, there is an increasingly popular phenomenon whereby people engage in a whole host of exotic activities under the guise of charity. Anything slightly extreme, unusual or silly will secure you good sponsorship if you present it properly wrapped up in good intentions. This win-win charity with its seductions of the spectacular will have you doing anything from ‘jumping out of an aeroplane’ to trekking through the mountains of Nepal.
I am not saying that people abuse the generosity of others simply to part fund a skydiving or trekking ambition; I have no doubt that there really are good intentions embedded in the business model. But it is said, I believe, that the road to hell is paved by good intentions.
On the face of it, everybody does seem to win. You have fun jetting off to Sydney on a free plane ticket, three thousand pounds is being better spent on water supplies than Christmas decorations and there’s a general sense of satisfaction for all involved. Enough money makes everything seem worthwhile. But if the ultimate goal is the eradication of poverties and social injustices, is it really an effective step to achieving it?
Money is not the be all and end all, even though at times it seems the only measure of success. It is a very powerful facilitator but is essentially just that, a means not an end. We certainly need money to tackle social injustice and poverty but we also need to bring about a change to the way we live.
There is much debate surrounding the causes and effects of poverty, but what is overwhelmingly apparent is that by some means – as untraceable, convoluted and esoteric as they may be in the global web of media we live in – it is the overconsumption of the rich that sustains the poverties suffered by the poor.
In 2005, the wealthiest 20% of the world accounted for 76.6% of total private consumption, the poorest fifth just 1.5% so unless we’re going to give away nearly three quarters of everything we own then poverty is not going to be eradicated by donations alone. Win-win gestures which siphon up people’s spare change are simply not enough.
But the win-win industry around charitable activity presents a greater problem than simply not providing a complete solution. If we are not careful with how we engage in finding a solution for social justice we can very quickly find ourselves strengthening the pathways of our society through which poverty and social injustice is maintained. The main problem with this win-win charity that gives us all a satisfied feeling and a quirky experience is just that; it leaves us all far too satisfied.
This type of charity is judged only on how much money we raise; indeed it is only justified by how much money is raised. We flaunt great sums of money as successes but disregard the costs incurred in raising it, and I do not mean financially. Sometimes we don’t even consider where the money is going to, only that it is ‘for charity’; that great homogenised blob of omnibenevolence.
Don’t get me wrong, I am not proposing more bureaucracy to clog the system up, that would only be counterintuitive, but I think this lack of concern reflects a greater sense of disempowerment that this type of charity engenders.
Charity becomes a transaction; the sale of our conscience becomes a service, our peace of mind a commodity to be bought. Ultimately we are left satisfied that we have done ‘our bit’.
It plays on a sense of a larger system that we think we can’t tackle as an individual. It plays on the overworked, overstressed nature of lives – all we can hope to do is use our surplus wealth to pay some large charity to do something on our behalf. It effectively anaesthetises people who may otherwise be more active.
Living in a global society where there is prolific and systematic dehumanization does not only affect those who are oppressed but those who oppress, even if they do so unknowingly.
The stress we feel to consume, to achieve and demonstrate our position in the world both nationally and individually is taking its toll. Many feel cornered and squashed into everyday life to such an extent that they begin to believe they have no power.
Such is this type of charity, increasingly ingrained in the economic system to such an extent that it has become a party to, and supportive of aspects of society which cause the very effects that it’s trying to counter.
This win-win charity is a relief method only in the sense that it helps the wealthy relieve their consciences in the most painless way possible, allowing them to carry on carelessly. It is a mechanism built into the system which perpetuates social injustice. It lulls us into a sense of inertia, and reassures us ‘that’s all we can do.’
Poverty can only be eradicated if charitable acts lead to engagement and further consciousness about our lifestyles – contrary to this, this charity is a system of disengagement. Poverty will only be eradicated if we, a global middle class, can accept the responsibility of our position as global citizens and consume responsibly.
We need to live our lives differently; we need to live within our means. This demands that we don’t feel satisfied at all – quite the opposite people need to feel incensed, enamoured and empowered; we need to believe that our lifestyle choices can make a difference, and understand that currently they are responsible.
In the face of giant multi-national institutions, and huge globalisation we have been oppressed by a feeling of helplessness, and so we revert to ‘doing what we can’.
And this, contrary to being exactly what we can do and need to do (the individual moderation of our consumption), has become a pseudo-spectacular system of novelties, competitive fundraising targets and misplaced good intentions.
Indignez-vous! As Stéphane Hessel demands, let’s take back our lives.
We must learn to trust that we have the ability to change the world in our lives alone. When you have taken what you need, give what you can. There is no need to make a show of it, a spectacle, or receive a pay off. Charity does not need to be self deprecating or sacrificial; just reasoned, humble and caring.

