Are classic fairy tales best left in the past?

By Emma Lucia Felisi

Sleeping Beauty, Cinderella, The Little Mermaid. These are fairy tales well-known to many. Most children have grown up with these stories, both as film and literature. The enchanting tale of a dainty princess saved by a knight in shining armour has captivated many generations throughout the years, and continues to do so. And by first glance, these stories do not seem to hold any deeper meaning, they are, all things considered, only children’s stories. And yet, the debate carries on – Keira Knightley stated in late 2018 that her daughter is banned from watching Cinderella, and other classic Disney films, with the female protagonists lacking agency.

Keira Knightley stated in late 2018 that her daughter is banned from watching Cinderella

But do the classic fairy tales really send the wrong message about gender roles to children? Do they give young girls the impression that they themselves, without a man, are not strong enough to handle problems they will face in the future? I find this doubtful. It’s important to consider the deeper meaning behind the statement made by Knightley, as it is a promising indication of a growing awareness in the 21st century of what we are teaching the next generation about gender roles. But is breaking down outdated gender roles achieved through banning our children from watching Disney movies and reading classic fairy tales?

I grew up with Disney movies embedded in my DNA. I lived and breathed fairy tales which revolved around princesses. I still became a feminist, and a strong believer in women, and men, breaking stereotypical gender boundaries. It is important to remember that children do not place the same value in media as adults do. For them it is merely entertainment, which can be counter-balanced easily through real life experiences.

Children do not place the same value in media as adults do

We should focus on improving the present and the future, by increasing diversity in gender expression and gender roles in new media. New media and literature are constantly breaking barriers and outdated stereotypes. By showing children contemporary media alongside the old, they’re exposed to a diverse set of female protagonists, some less independent than others, but this is real life. Not everybody’s the same, and it’s important to make the next generation of adults understand this from an early age, creating a more accepting future for ourselves and for our children.

And even though the classic fairy tales do not empower women in a modern sense, the dainty and vulnerable princesses still have admirable character traits that young girls can look up to. The Little Mermaid was feisty and kept fighting for what she wanted, despite everyone she loved not believing in her. Cinderella was abused for most of her life, but she never gave up on her dreams. Yes, these dreams were realised by meeting men, the princesses are flawed, but again, so are people in the real world. By teaching children the good and bad aspects, it creates an understanding of the world as more layered and complicated than just black and white.

The world can learn from its mistakes by keeping them in mind for the future

The past is not just something to erase as fast as possible, it’s something we can learn from, both its positives and negatives. The world can learn from its mistakes by keeping them in mind for the future, not by forgetting them. By remembering and learning from the past, we can improve the present and secure the future.

Photograph: Cederic X via Unsplash