Review: The Baron in the Trees

By Carolina Maberry

The Baron in the Trees by Italo Calvino provides a roadmap for navigating the strange age we live in. Difficult to explain with a straight face, Calvino treats the narrative with a deadpan seriousness that sweeps you along.

Cosimo Piovasco di Rondo is the eldest son of a Duke in the Italian region of Liguria just before the Enlightenment sparks. The book is somewhat obsessively narrated by his little brother, Biagio. Fed up with the pomp and procedure his father demands, Cosimo’s rebellion is to climb into the great oak tree in their garden and refuse to come down. Qucikly, Cosimo realizes he’s never going to set foot on the ground again as he learns the oak connects to the grand forest of the neighbouring aristocrats. From there the whole of the region is open to him. Cosimo makes new friends, learns new skills, and creates a life for himself in the trees.

A fairy-tale coming-of-age novel, but what sets it apart is this subtle air of parody

If you’re familiar at all with any Latin American magical realist fiction you’ll feel very at home here. Every time you’re ready to get used to Cosimo’s new life in the trees, he meets and befriends a sappy romantic bandit or recruits a daschund to help with hunting. The novel is ultimately a fairy-tale coming-of-age novel, but what sets it apart is this subtle air of parody.

When it was written, the novel was reflecting on the not-so-distant past of Italian fascism and dictatorship, which Italo Calvino felt robbed him of his childhood. Basing itself in the nostalgic joy of childhood, Cosimo’s actions are treated with a sort of sacrosanct level of detail by his brother. How he gets water, how he sleeps, or how he fashions clothes are all carefully explained in the narration. The novel is uncluttered by the trappings of a normal life that obscure our vision and can make unimportant things like table etiquette seem vital.

The book is about navigating individualism

In the trees, Cosimo has found a way to take the good and leave the bad of his world. He devours the new progress in thought and science coming from the Enlightenment era while keeping his distance from the danger of a rapidly dying old way of life. The book is about navigating individualism; balancing your connection with the real world and your connection to yourself. A book to be reading at this time in life; we are pulled between family and freedom and facing a lot of insecurity about the future. The novel points out that everyone has their own version of Cosimo’s escape going on.

The classic criticism of the novel is that it gets a little strained as Cosimo grows older. It’s true; the more time that passes, the less the reader can take the premise at face value and the novel loses something. Cosimo’s world becomes a lot more complex very suddenly, balancing love, soldiers, and foreign influences from up in the trees. He struggles to understand people, perhaps as a result of his strange upbringing. Things get difficult, and the nostalgic fairy tale atmosphere wanes.

Cosimo, ironically, stays grounded

We’re in a shaky new golden age, where the internet was supposed to be of the same sort of egalitarian principles as the Enlightenment. But just like Calvino shows, these times are prone to fast change and not all of it can be good. Cosimo, ironically, stays grounded. He keeps his distance and his identity and at a time where nothing seems sure, he stays in the trees.

Photograph: Gaetano Cessati via Unsplash.