A study in crime: If I Die Before I Wake

By Milly Munro

If I Die Before I Wake is the debut novel from Emily Koch and has one of the most intriguing premises I’ve ever seen in a crime novel. Alex, an avid rock climber and journalist, is stuck in hospital in a vegetative state and has been for two years after a climbing accident. He can’t move, speak or communicate in any way. Unbeknownst to his family, friends and doctors, Alex can hear and feel everything that goes on around him. Alex can’t remember anything about his accident and only knows what his friends and family read to him in newspaper reports. What seems to be an innocent accident slowly unravels into a murder mystery against the clock as Alex struggles to find out what happened to him without being able to move or speak.

one of the most intriguing premises I’ve ever seen in a crime novel

The novel has a slow start as Koch establishes the characters and their roles in the novel. Alex is frequently visited by his worried and struggling girlfriend Bea, his seemingly cold-hearted sister Philippa and his father. There’s also a circle of doctors and nurses who tend to Alex in the hope that he shows any sign of recovery. Koch doesn’t reveal that the accident may have been something more sinister until halfway through the novel and carefully feeds titbits of information slowly to keep the reader turning the page. The novels suspense then doubles; the reader is in a race to find out who the attacker is and if Alex will ever wake up. As Alex is trying to solve his own attempted murder in his head, he also has to deal with the possibility of his family deciding to turn off his life support. Koch manages to keep a great balance between suspenseful and emotional as Alex’s friends and family struggle with an ongoing police investigation as well as the possibility that their friend may never wake up.

The list of potential suspects only grows as the novel goes on; the spotlight switches from Bea, whose relationship with Alex is not as rosy as it first seems, to Alex’s climbing partner whose movements on the day of Alex’s accident are kept hidden, to an unknown attacker who may now be targeting Bea. The novel is told entirely from Alex’s point of view which makes his frustration all the more is palpable. Alex, and the reader, is completely reliant on whatever information his visitors or doctors let slip around him. Even when the police arrest someone for Alex’s attack, Alex is completely powerless to do anything.

this novel definitely establishes Koch’s name as an exciting writer in crime fiction

This is a tense, suspenseful novel which slowly builds up into an absolute page turner. Koch balances the twisting, thrilling development of Alex’s investigation into his own attempted murder, the emotional grief taking its toll on his loved ones, and his own frustration and desperation at his state. As a debut, this novel definitely establishes Koch’s name as an exciting writer in crime fiction.