An argument for theme – Ernest Hemmingway’s A Farewell to Arms

By Charlie Bennett

We are taught in school, that the way ‘into’ any good novel, poem or play is to think about themes. Theme has become a monolith and a marker of secondary-age education in literature; ask GCSE students what Exposure and War Photographer have in common, and their answer will inevitably bookmark death, war and the body as the ‘key themes’. They aren’t making a mistake in doing this, indeed the most popular exam board for GCSE English Literature, AQA, partially defines the activity of ‘critical reading’ as “identifying the theme and distinguishing between themes”.

But then we move on, or we think we do, and we come to books with the misplaced hope that we might somehow engage in critical reading without a reduction of the text into what we perceive as ‘oversimplified themes’. In our best moments we hope not only to maintain, but indeed to add; to give more than the book alone can give by providing additional detail in the form of infinitesimally specific nuggets of context or by breaking down language into all manner of constituent devices. I am by no means calling this practice unnecessary, on the contrary it is essential, but it does tend to encounter an unfortunate paradox: the more detail we seek and the more specific we become in an effort to let go of the perceived weakness of ‘general themes’ – the more we lose our grip on the totality of the text, we are running Zeno’s footrace getting forever further from the finish line.

I haven’t brought up this problem because I have a neat solution, like all paradoxes there isn’t one, but it is a problem that seemed very prescient when I began to read Ernest Hemmingway’s 1929 novel A Farewell to Arms. This novel is a provocation to the essayist, it asks us to simultaneously appreciate the beautifully innocuous observations: “the gravel paths were moist, and the grass was wet with dew”, all the while, Hemmingway refuses to let us take our eyes off the bigger themes, the looming ever-present fact that “there’s a war on – you know”. The themes at play here run the gambit of hyper-canonical story elements: death, war, love and religion just to name a few. I naively thought I had seen these themes thousands of times, iterated in so many ways, that I was above the call to read critically by distinguishing them, I felt I was familiar with them. Hemmingway refutes this narrow lens.

Theme has become a monolith and a marker of secondary-age education in literature

We follow lieutenant Frederic Henry, an American ambulance driver fighting with the Italian’s during the twelfth battle of the Isonzo, the battle of Caporetto. Henry is a man at sea in a world of ideas torn between the orthodoxy of his unit’s Priest who argues for a divine love of God that “You wish to sacrifice for. You wish to serve”, and the mortal devotion of the nurse Catherine with whom Henry falls in love. Henry experiences a watershed moment as the Italian offensive turns into a chaotic retreat, trying to sneak back into friendly lines with his fellow ambulance drivers. Suddenly, they are fired upon by Italian troops, petrified of German infiltrators, hitting one of Henry’s men: “Aymo lay in the mud within the angle of the embankment. He was quite small, and his arms were by his side, his putty wrapped legs and muddy boots together, his cap over his face. He looked very dead. It was raining. I had liked him as well as anyone I ever knew.” The rain that had wetted the gravel paths returns to baptise Henry in the senseless tragedy of conflict as he crosses a Rubicon of his own by plunging into the Tagliamento river. His faith, love and the war become inseparable in the small “very dead” man, as good and standard as anyone, who could have been anyone, who could have just as easily been lieutenant Henry. Hemmingway spends the novel splicing themes together in this way. Love, for instance, becomes a way to probe the theme of religion. For one very limited example, the Priest challenges Henry by declaring:

“You understand but you do not love God.’

‘No.’ […]

‘You should love him”

Yet when Catherine lies dying in a Swiss hospital, Henry’s desperation reintroduces love into the religious theme: “Don’t let her die. Oh, God, please don’t let her die. I’ll do anything for you if you won’t let her die. Please, please, please, dear God, don’t let her die.”

We need to see the rain both in its totality and as individual drops

Hemmingway’s trick is to remind us how inescapable these themes are, just when we think Henry is free from the impact of war or God we are reminded just how intertwined the thematic strands have become. As such, Henry ends the novel by rejecting the demands to continue on and explore these themes further, instead he, “left the hospital and walked back to the hotel in the rain”. The throughline metaphor of the rain is an apt echo of the difficulties a text like Hemmingway’s presents: we need to see the rain both in its totality and as individual drops, to appreciate the small meaningful textual details without getting so bogged down as to miss the overall thematic strokes. I make no claim to have done this; I am sceptical if the perfect balance is possible. But I hope that in this very short time I have at least made clear the problem, and I might have been able to encourage you to read Hemmingway’s work with an attention to the multiple levels it is operating on, all beautifully necessary, but nevertheless difficult to keep in a simultaneous view. A Farewell to Arms is in my opinion one of the greatest war-novels and I have made sure not to excessively spoil the depths of its tragedy in the hope that you will get to enjoy its heart-rending handling of theme and detail for yourself.

Image: Lloyd Arnold (Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons)