Strider: the tragedy of man in the story of a horse

By Charlie Bennett

In some ways, Leo Tolstoy’s Strider: Story of a Horse is exactly what it purports to be. It is one of eleven short pieces of prose in the collection: The Devil and Other Stories. Tolstoy recounts the tale of the eponymous Strider, an old piebald gelding, who lives with a herd of younger horses who alienate him because “he was old, they were young; he was lean, they were sleek”. The narrative begins with “the sounds of snorting, the rustling of litter, and even the shrill angry neighing of horses crowded together and squabbling”. The setting is perfectly ordinary and we see that Strider, who is the chosen horse of the herdsman Nester, lives a calm but ultimately lonely and isolating existence grazing on his own away from the herd.

Strider speaks for the first time and distinguishes himself as a most unusual horse and narrator

However, it soon becomes clear that Tolstoy is not content to simply offer a fable-like, if melancholic, picture of Strider’s life. Instead, Tolstoy takes the step that has made this story a classic example of literary defamiliarization; Tolstoy gives Strider a voice. “Yes, I am son of Affable I and of Baba. My pedigree name is Muzhik I. I am Muzhik I by pedigree and I was nicknamed Strider by the crowd because of my long and sweeping strides, the like of which was nowhere to be found in all Russia” — with this quasi-biblical tone, Strider speaks for the first time and distinguishes himself as a most unusual horse and narrator. This equine narration is often the predominant focus in analyses of this story; with emphasis being placed on the way it distorts our usual view of the world. But Strider’s story is not wholly unfamiliar, indeed much of the story is made of the tragedy of a very human existence. As I hope to show, Strider’s suffering is distinctly human in both character and manufacture. He is a victim of the cruelties, inequalities and greed of humanity yet in the face of it all Strider is a regenerative symbol of hope and new life.

Strider spends five nights retelling his life story to his fellow horses, he recalls how “the happiest years of my life I spent with the hussar officer […] life was worth living then”. These were by no means easy years for Strider, they took his “best qualities and half [his] life” from him, but they were years spent in the service of a man whom he respected, the hussar Serpuphovskoy. These scenes are particularly gut-wrenching because Strider’s longing for the past is so actively contrasted by the steady decline of his body: “the sagging lip revealed a blackish, bitten tongue and the yellow stumps of the worn-down lower teeth. […] the expression on his face was one of stern patience, thoughtfulness and suffering”. Strider’s tragedy is not just his age, but his feeling that even when he was young and healthy he was never put to the fullest use of his abilities. On multiple occasions Strider declares himself to have been exceptionally fast and yet, after his two years spent with the hussar officer, he is sold to a “peasant” and made to plough a field. There is something so abjectly human about Strider’s feeling of hopelessness, the weight of time, legacy and mortality are not things I typically associate with animals and yet Tolstoy revels in the brutal humanising of Strider as a horse who “ponder[s] the injustice of men, who blamed me for being a piebald”.

Despite all the torment he has suffered at the hands of humanity, despite the betrayals and loneliness he is subjected to by the other horses, Strider ends his life still giving back to the world which took so much from him

The story has an equally bleak ending, as Strider becomes ill he is visited by the knacker who walks with him and Nester. Yet, in a final twist in a story which is already so unusual, Tolstoy does not kill Strider in a moment of abject misery. Instead, the scene embodies the kind of complex, morbid beauty which has characterised Strider’s whole life: “he felt something liquid streaming down his neck and chest. He heaved a profound sigh and felt much better. The whole burden of his life was eased. He closed his eyes and began to droop his head”. In his final moments, Strider is relieved of the burden of human suffering he has been made to bear for his whole life. Strider is not ceremoniously buried, his body is left to the dogs, but even in this last act his body is still made to serve others. As the final chapter draws to a close Strider’s body is seen sustaining new life: “in a ravine of the old forest, down in an overgrown glade, big-headed wolf cubs were howling joyfully” gorging themselves on “horse flesh”. Despite all the torment he has suffered at the hands of humanity, despite the betrayals and loneliness he is subjected to by the other horses, Strider ends his life still giving back to the world which took so much from him.

Image: Evelyn Simak via Wikimedia Commons