An analysis of new European strategy in the face of President Trump’s urge to “go-it alone”

By Daisy Rought-Oram

In the lead up to the third anniversary of Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, European leaders are being forced to come to terms with a seemingly sudden departure by the US from the combined effort to bring an end to the war in Ukraine. As President Donald Trump forefronts a US-led “go-it-alone” strategy, leaders; diplomats; and foreign policy specialists are adopting new strategies to adapt to the changing geopolitical atmosphere.

Mr Trump has not shied away from arguably-inflammatory rhetoric in recent weeks; he has made comments about the status of Canada as a “51st US state”, and has brought into question Greenland’s status as an autonomous territory within the Kingdom of Denmark. Such a pattern of language raises concerns regarding the extent to which President Trump will “tread carefully” when it comes to bartering a peace deal. Such concerns are compounded by Mr Trump’s choice of representative; Middle East envoy, Bronx-born billionaire real-estate developer, and “golf buddy” of the President, Steve Witkoff was, last week, chosen to spend “about three hours” with President Putin as part of the US efforts to broker a peace deal. Mr Witkoff’s designated importance to this mammoth geopolitical task is indicative of Mr Trump’s approach to the presidency. A distinctively “Trumpian presidency” appears to be emerging; one which likes to evade checks, and puts rhetoric at the centre of political and diplomatic strategy.

Mr Trump’s “lengthy and productive” phone call with Vladimir Putin, in which the two leaders agreed to “start negotiations immediately” sent shockwaves throughout Europe. With Mr Trump’s statement that he would meet with President Putin in Saudi Arabia to imminently begin negotiations, Ukrainian President Zelensky asserted that he would not accept any agreement made without Ukraine’s involvement. The Ukrainian President later spoke with Trump to discuss plans for a “lasting, reliable peace”, and agreed to meet Vice President JD Vance in the immediate future. 

With Europe anxiously watching and waiting, the annual Munich Security Conference was set to take place over the weekend of the 14th-16th February, with Mr Zelensky; Mr Vance; NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte; and a host of world leaders in attendance. Mr Vance shocked the room into silence as he spouted a wave of criticism of European allies, accusing European governments of “retreating from their values”, and spending far too little on defence. One wonders what of Mr Vance’s own values were guiding his, perhaps poorly-judged, approach to diplomacy. 

The anxiety of European leaders manifested itself in an emergency summit at the Elysee Palace on Monday 17th February, the day before talks in Saudi Arabia were set to begin. German Chancellor Olaf Scholz said at the emergency Paris summit that Europe and the US must not be divided over Ukraine; a major fallout between the US and Europe could threaten the strength of a peace deal. President Trump, while bringing the unwavering determination to achieve peace for Ukraine (whatever the cost?), commands a team that could be seen to  lack the diplomatic nous and ardent anti-Putin feeling held by his European counterparts. After Tuesday 17th’s talks in Saudi Arabia – which did not include European delegates – Russian officials suggested that the Trump administration marked a new tone of US-Russian diplomacy; Mr Trump’s style was “unlike the Biden administration, which never tried to hear Russia’s position”. Kirill Dimitriev added, “we got to know each other much better”. Likely concerns following such discussions, as outlined by Stephen Collinson (CNN), relate to the prospect of a hurried peace deal that works to appease and strengthen Russia; in validating Mr Putin’s desired expansionism, the future security of Ukraine, and indeed Europe, runs the risk of being undermined.

The propensity for a rift between the US and Europe does not seem impossible. Disagreements already exist regarding Ukraine’s NATO status; Sir Keir Starmer has asserted that Ukraine is on an “irreversible path to NATO membership”, while US Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has said “the US does not believe that NATO membership for Ukraine is a realistic outcome of a negotiated settlement”. 

The propensity for a rift between the US and Europe does not seem impossible. Disagreements already exist regarding Ukraine’s NATO status

Sir Keir Starmer, in a show of vehement support for Ukraine on Sunday 16th February, said he was “ready and willing” to put troops on the ground in order to protect a peace deal. A day later, calls for a “US backstop” followed, though the Prime Minister remained elusive regarding the specificities of this. European presence in Ukraine, and the prospect of a “backstop”, rings true of NATO ideals; Starmer seems serious in his resolve to offer NATO membership to Ukraine. 

But on the evening of the 18th, Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov refuted possibilities of NATO, EU or UK peacekeepers in Ukraine; “it is simply unacceptable”. Lavrov’s judgement of peacekeeping troops as indistinguishable from active fighters alludes to a wider concern about the nature of ‘peacekeepers’. Were NATO troops to position themselves along the border of the Russian-Ukrainian border following a peace deal, and active conflict was to resume, the status of the peacekeepers would be brought into question. Would they engage in armed conflict, bringing NATO into the war, or would they rapidly withdraw, questioning the necessity of their impact there in the first place. 

The active display of European strength and unity in the face of difficulty hopefully indicates that a peaceful and sovereign future for Ukraine is possible. European leaders have united around the idea that the security, stability, and longevity of peace are instrumental for Ukraine, and for the future of European security. But this new European strategy is not without complications; President Macron leads a fragile government after last summer’s decision to call parliamentary elections, and the German federal election on 23rd February could leave Germany without a new coalition government for a number of weeks while discussions are ongoing. The popularity of the far-right AfD – who are currently polling at 21% –  brings further questions about the potential for a shift in German diplomatic strategy. Chancellor Scholz has been an outspoken member of the European community in recent days – an increasingly powerful section of right wing populists could bring this into jeopardy.

With Zelensky’s visible disgruntlement at his sidelining, and with Mr Trump having critiqued Ukraine for having had “three years” to negotiate peace when asked about the exclusion of Ukrainian officials from the negotiating table, US-Ukraine relations are fraught. Comments on the morning of the 19th February that President Trump is “living in a disinformation space” demonstrates growing doubt in the US’ capability to administer peace in Europe, and a growing distrust about the nature of such peace. While the US’ status as an ally to Ukraine is undermined, President Zelensky is increasingly turning to Europe for his country’s security. 

European defence budgets, governments in flux, and the apparent US monopoly on peace talks make the next few days and weeks crucial for the future of Ukraine, Europe, and the status of the continent’s partnership with the US.

Image Credit: Saeima via Wikimedia Commons