All we imagine as Indian cinema
By Tilottama Chowdhury
Indian cinema has long been synonymous with Bollywood, known for its melodramatic storytelling and vibrant dance sequences. But equating all of Indian cinema solely to Bollywood is a disservice to the country’s diversely rich filmmaking. Beyond the star-studded world of Bollywood lie deeply evocative films that challenge conventions, speak to universal human emotions, and represent the complexities of common people.Â
Recently, among the voices redefining Indian cinema, Payal Kapadia’s groundbreaking work has offered a contemplative departure from mainstream narratives. She became the first Indian director to win the Grand Prix at the Cannes International Film Festival 2024. Her feature, All We Imagine As Light, has since won several International awards and was nominated for the 82nd Golden Globe Award. The primarily Malayalam film delves into the lives of three women grappling with personal loss and systemic injustice in contemporary India. Payal Kapadia has carved a niche visual style which is almost painterly – each frame feels like a canvas smeared with anguish and hope, with storytelling that is neither linear nor comforting but profoundly human. Kapadia’s palette is as delicate as the memories she paints: a rustling curtain in a breeze, the way sunlight falls on an empty chair, a glance heavy with unspoken words. The meditative approach of the film is a far cry from the exuberance of Bollywood; instead, it offers a poignant reflection on the intimate and often silent struggles of womanhood and resilience.
“Each frame feels like a canvas smeared with anguish and hope, with storytelling that is neither linear nor comforting but profoundly human”
To understand Kapadia’s work is to see it as a thread in a larger tapestry. Think of Ritesh Batra’s The Lunchbox (2013), nominated for Best Film BAFTA 2015. It is a heartwarming exploration of loneliness, human connection and how “the wrong train can sometimes get you to the right station”, told through a misplaced dabba that sparks an accidental correspondence between a widower and a neglected housewife in Mumbai. The film uses the unique dabba delivery service, and the Mumbai local, the lifeline of the city to create an understated method of storytelling. This isn’t the city of chase sequences and luxury, it’s a maze of anonymous lives with motifs such as noisy ceiling fans, crowded evening trains and conversations through ajar windows which punctuate the day like brief, unexpected poetry.
Rewind to Satyajit Ray’s Pather Panchali (transl. Song of the Little Road), another testament to the power of Indian cinema. It won Best Human Document at Cannes in 1956 and Best Film at the 1958 BAFTA’s. This classic, which marked the beginning of Ray’s iconic Apu Trilogy, captures the tender yet stark realities of rural life in Bengal through a brother-sister duo, Apu and Durga. Ray tells the story of Apu’s childhood – a story so steeped in the mundane that it feels almost sacred. The rain on a thatched roof, the laughter of children as they chase a train – movements that carry the weight of entire lifetimes. With its neorealist approach, the Bengali film foregrounds the everyday struggles of an impoverished family, a story of survival and deferred dreams. The train soon becomes a symbol of this, as Durga is unable to watch the train with Apu ever again. The train also becomes a part of the following films in the trilogy as Apu finally gets on the train to embark on his journey to become a man of the world. Ray’s influence is evident in the works of filmmakers like Kapadia, who prioritize realism and emotional depth over commercial appeal.
For every choreographed Bollywood spectacle, there’s a Payal Kapadia, bending light to tell stories of dark corners and whispered dreams. There’s a Ritesh Batra, wrapping silence around heartbreak like a protective sheath. There’s a Satyajit Ray, who, decades ago, showed the world that a village boy’s journey was epic enough to stand alongside any hero’s quest. These films are a call to see this other India, the one where stories speak in the language of everyday acts—a shared meal, a burning lamp, a summer mango. These films do not shout; they hum like an old tune you can’t quite place but will never forget.
“These films do not shout; they hum like an old tune you can’t quite place but will never forget”
Ray’s haunting rural landscapes and Kapadia’s meditative storytelling sings of an India too layered for a single note. These films highlight the evolving landscape of Indian cinema, one that stretches beyond the dance floors of Bollywood, into kitchens, classrooms, and quiet streets at dawn. What unites these films is their ability to move beyond caricatures and simplistic narratives to portray the realities of Indian society. Indian cinema is a medium of crafting films that are both intimate whispers and urgent shouts in the ears of an audience ready to listen. They invite global audiences to see India through a lens that is introspective and humane, far removed from the stereotypes perpetuated upon mainstream Bollywood. These films redefine what it means to watch Indian cinema; they demand engagement, not just entertainment.
Illustration: Ashley Zhou

