‘The Holdovers’, and the privilege of joy at Christmas

By Tamzin Meadows

Many of you may hold the opinion that Christmas films should be strictly joyous and magical, full to the brim with fun and festivities. For many people, that is what Christmas represents in a more secular world. To me, Christmas is all about comfort – it’s a warm hug from a loved one and smiling so much my face starts to ache. It’s getting cosy by a fire, eating some good food and, most of all, spending time with those you love. The latter is extremely special, as it not always a given, but instead a privilege.

It is fair to say that most, if not all, Christmas films are primarily joyous and feel-good. Most of them centre spending time with your loved ones – think Hugh Grant’s opening and closing monologues in Love Actually,‘If you look for it, I’ve got a sneaky feeling you’ll find that love actually is all around’. But the reality is that sometimes love and joy do not feel as though they are all around. While many classic Christmas films do touch on this topic – Alan Rickman’s character cheating in Love Actually, for example, or Scrooge’s general hate for others and innate loneliness in all the various iterations of A Christmas Carol, even the Muppet’s version! – none do as poignantly, in my opinion, as The Holdovers.

‘The Holdovers’ (2023) is a film that hits home how, with all the festivities that may surround the holidays, it’s the time we spend with each other that stands out above all else

The Holdovers (2023) is a film that hits home how, with all the festivities that may surround the holidays, it’s the time we spend with each other that stands out above all else. Directed by Alexander Payne, The Holdovers is a narrative of grief, love, and family. Set at a New England boarding school in the 1970s, the narrative follows teacher Paul Hunham (Paul Giamatti), who is tasked with looking after the titular ‘holdovers’ – boys who have to stay at school over the holidays. Over the course of the holidays we watch as Hunham, rebellious school-boy Angus Tully (Dominic Sessa), and grieving head cook Mary Lamb (Da’Vine Joy Randolph) form an unlikely bond.

Suffering from an unfortunate post-Christmas release date in the UK and only hitting the cinemas on January 19th, it is a film that may have slipped under the radar for many, and I feel it my duty to put this beautiful piece of cinema into your Christmas film rotation if it is not already there!

If I were to describe The Holdovers in three words it’d be the following: raw, cathartic, and wholesome. These may not necessarily strike you as very festive terms, but I believe that it is in its raw and visceral depiction of grief, loneliness, and found family that this film in fact embodies the spirit of Christmas. Payne does not shy away from depicting the harsh realities of life; they are open wounds on full display. Mary’s grief at the loss of her son is both touching and devastating, and Da’Vine Joy Randolph ensures that you feel this loss as your own through the screen. Tully’s abandonment by his recently remarried mother, and his desperation to see his father – which ultimately contributes to the emotional climax of the film – are raw and visceral. And Hunham’s overall cynicism, and general lack of direction, leaves you with both pity and respect for a man that was dealt unfortunate cards in life. 

Payne creates a strikingly human narrative […] and furthermore a cathartic one, because sometimes we all need a good cry at Christmas, and a reminder that little moments of joy can be found even in the hardest of times

It is not by disregarding or ignoring their pain that these three experience love, but by embracing it. It is in being open, emotional, and bare that these three lonely protagonists are able to connect with each other, despite being so utterly different. There is a magic in the film’s emotional climaxes: in Mary’s breakdown at the party and in her giving of her late son’s baby clothes to her sister in Tully’s visit to his father, a moment of vulnerability for the young rebel, and in Hunham’s righteous sacrifice for Tully at the film’s end. By giving us these representations of pain, difficulty, and grief on screen, Payne creates a strikingly human narrative, and thus a strikingly realistic one, and furthermore a cathartic one, because sometimes we all need a good cry at Christmas, and a reminder that little moments of joy can be found even in the hardest of times.

The Holdovers’ most poignant message, in my opinion, is this: many people have a hard time at Christmas, and joy is not a given, so kindness goes a long way. Life is hard, and life doesn’t stop being hard because it’s suddenly the holidays – for many it gets harder! Hug your friends and family tight, be kind and open-minded, and spread joy where you can!

Illustration: Ashley Zhou