Aidan’s students protest collective punishment for fire door damage
By Frank Kelly
Students at St Aidan’s College have sent an open letter objecting to the threat of collective fines for fire door damage. Students sent an open letter in response to an incident on the 14th January, where fire doors at the college were vandalised.
The open letter sets out a number of reasons why students at the college think that the threat of collective fines for such damage is unjustified. The letter asks, “How can you justify a collective economic punishment despite this violating well-established moral principles of punishment?”.
The letter also questions how the college can justify “the extreme excessiveness of fining hundreds of people for the actions of one, especially when those very same people aided you in giving general information about the event?”.
“How can you justify a collective economic punishment despite this violating well-established moral principles of punishment?”
Open letter by St Aidan’s students
No fines have been issued presently in relation to damage done to the fire doors. The principal of St Aidan’s College, Dr Susan Frenk, responded to the open letter, explaining that collective fines have to be issued in cases where those who vandalised the door do not inform the college. In response to the letter, the principal said, “there is no magic pot of gold, even in the rainbow college, to pay for acts of deliberate destruction.
“In fact the Fire Doors were installed just last term, at significant cost, to protect everyone, mandated by the local Fire Service inspections.
“Until two years ago, a sum was ring-fenced from the residence fees in each college, to pay for unattributable damage where those responsible did not come forward. That has ceased, because it was seen as encouraging a lack of personal responsibility and penalising innocent students. Yet without it, we have had to introduce collective payment in the areas where damage is inflicted.”
On 21st October last year, residents of ‘C curve’ in Aidan’s College were also threatened with a £200 collective fine. Fire doors at the end of the corridor were damaged, and the college informed students that, “we will have to distribute the repair costs among all residents and consider further action which could involve a £200 fine for breach of fire safety.”
In response to the damage inflicted on the 14th January, Dr Frenk said, “Such behaviour seriously breaches the student pledge sworn by all Durham University students and goes completely against the St Aidan’s culture and ethos of respect and kindness.”
Image: St Aidan’s College

