Correspondence
I notice that “What would God say to a Muslim?” was the title of one of the talks given by the DICCU in November 2004. No doubt that created controversy, too.
I have no objection to the DICCU giving such inflammatory talks, as long as they can back up their claims and allow their opposition a say. In short, as long as it is reasonably academic.
What I do object to, though, is their calling themselves a “Christian Union” while excluding the Church which makes up two thirds of Christians worldwide. They should call themselves the Protestant Union, or even the Evangelical Protestant Union (the DICEPU?); members of CathSoc, after all, may belief that their Church is the only legitimate Latin-rite one, but do not call themselves the Christian Society
Mark Harmstone
The whole purpose of the “Big Question” talks that DICCU hosts on Friday lunchtimes is to answer questions put by Durham students last year. It it the ultimate venture in openness – literally answering the questions people want to know about what Christians believe.
In this case, I am not aware of the DSU refusing to host a CathSoc response. I would have thought, though, that the onus is not on DICCU to provide a platform for it.
As for the name – Christians of all flavours have decided to identify themselves in various ways; which is only natural. DICCU chooses to define “Christian” as “Bible-believing”, which, again, is not at all unreasonable. As you will have discovered at the talk on Roman Catholicism, that DICCU uses such a defnition is no secret.
Ali Gledhill
I must confess to be rather confused by Mr Gledhill’s comment. Is he alleging that catholics do not believe in the bible? If so, I was horribly mislead for the entire thirteen years that I attended catholic school. It also makes the many hours we spent studying the bible seem rather pointless!
Clare Nicholl
As the speaker at the event, I would like to just point out a few things. I know these won’t deal with all of the wider issues being discussed but I feel they are important:
1. ‘The intention of [the talk] was to explain why Catholics are going to Hell’ That is a very inflammatory and extremely inaccurate reading of my talk. I never once made this statement – please check the audio recording on the DICCU website.
2. On questions – it was not a case of me just taking the questions I liked. There was a 45 minute open question time afterwards where around 100 people stayed behind and I took questions from the floor. This was very open and Catholics had plenty of chances to grill me and express their disagreement. Again PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE make sure you have your facts right before you make these sorts of sweeping comments on public posts like this. You article is simply not true at important points and given that antyone who goes to the DICCU website will see my name I feel it is very unfair that you should protray me in this way.
3. A number of Catholics came up to me afterwards to say that they thought that my analsysis of Catholicism was accurate but that they disagreed with my interpretation of the Bible. They thanked me for the gracious way I handled the issue. I feel this was a constructive exploration of the differences between Catholicism and Protestantism. I stressed twice in the talk and at least once in question time that Catholics and Protestants are to be nothing but gracious, kind and loving to one another. We have serious differences that prevent any kind of offcial union and I was very clear on what those differences are and why they matter, but in no way was I urging anything but respect and consideration for Catholics. Surely, tolerance means being able to discuss our differnces and live together. In my talk I quoted the late Cardinal Avery Dulles – a prominent RC theologian who made the point that what unites Catholics and Protestants is an understanding that truth matters.
4. Your conclusion was very difficult for me to read. I did not preach ‘against’ a section of the student body; I DID provide opportunity for open debate and crticism; it was not an ‘anti-Catholic’ sermon. I would be very grateful if you could quickly address the way you have misrepresented me. I feel you have been very very unfair in how you have represented me and my talk.
Peter Orr
See palatinate.org.uk/comment for more. Submit letters/responses to letters@palatinate.org.uk
