The balancing act
A PERENNIALLY-LEVELLED criticism of Palatinate is that the newspaper is too “safe” a student publication; too cautious, conservative and middle-of-the-road.
Sometimes, such sentiments are relatively justified, at least judging by what ends up going to print. Many an edition has sailed by in the past without eminating even a whiff of controversy.
The reasons for this, of course, are multitudinous. For one, Durham is a pretty uncontroversial sort of place; a place where flashers lurking around bridges are front page news.
For another, even when groundbreaking stories do emerge, Palatinate has historically all too often been hamstrung by its accountability to Durham Students’ Union, which, over the years, has seen countless investigations either modified beyond recognition or barred from publication altogether.
This second point is clearly an important one. While Palatinate is theoretically wholly editorially independent of its benefactor, in practice every
edition is screened for contentious content prior to going to print by two full-time Union employees.
This is because, as a publication of Durham Students’ Union, any libelous or otherwise illegal material printed in Palatinate can potentially saddle the Union with virtually unlimited liability.
Yet this situation also gives rise to a blatant conflict of interest. Should an article chastise the Union or even make outright disparaging comments about it, the content in question could well find itself censored solely on the grounds of taste.
Or at least it could have done. In January, Palatinate gained constitutionally-recognised editorial independence for the first time. While the new constitution is by no means perfect (by any account), it does at the very least guarantee that content can effectively only be prohibited from being published should it be illegal. Be under no illusions about how difficult this provision was to secure.
So, is Palatinate going to start running hard-hitting reports about gangland murders, sex scandals and fraudsters? Well, yes and no. It is still the case that very little happpens in this quaint little city, which naturally poses one or two challenges to our staff.
But at least we can finally report the big stories.
