Comment Editorial
We appreciate the Vice-Chancellor taking time to respond to our news cycle. We also appreciate his noble Voltairean insistence that the university should not interfere with the content of Palatinate, regardless of how much it might disapprove of our news values.
But it remains unclear from Prof. Higgins’s article what exactly there was to be sniffed at about the news story in question. In the Christmas edition of last term, we revealed that an academic event entitled ‘Iranian Theocracy and Democracy: Contradiction or Convergence?’ would be sponsored by the Iranian government. And so it was. The truth of the matter is not in dispute, merely whether to publish this information was to imply an unreasonable question.
The question is simply this: Is it likely that the Iranian government would involve itself in a forum on the subject of its own political system if it expected that forum to ferment ideas dissenting significantly from the government line? If not, does this undermine the academic worth of such an event? These questions could be asked about any government funding academic events about themselves, but it would be strange not to notice that Iran is a country with a poor human rights record, with substantial government involvement in the media and with harsh treatment of dissidents.
Additially, there are two aspects of the story which remain unexplored either by Prof. Higgins’ article or by Dr. Reza Molavi’s official statement last December. The first is the implication of the Islamic Republic News Agency press release we quoted, from which it is evident that the fact that Durham is hosting this event was used in Iran as propaganda for the government. Do we want it to be said of our university that, in however small a way, we acquiesced in the machinations of conservative forces within Iran? This in the run up to an election in which, fingers crossed, the reform candidate Khatami will defeat Channel 4’s darling, Ahmadinejad.
The second is the fact that the listings for the event on the university website did not give any full sense of the subject matter. Only the first lecture of several, Prof. Melville’s on the Persian poet Ferdowsi, was included on the listings. To note this is not to impugn the motives of the compiler, but merely to request that in future – if it is firmly the university’s view that it is kosher for the Iranian theocracy to sponsor Durham academic events about Iranian theocracy – that the nature of such events be made clear in the listings.
It’s not exactly Watergate, we admit. But to have raised such questions is a not a bad day’s work for an amateur student rag. It’s just a pity our Vice-Chancellor appears to disagree: perhaps he would like to run Palatinate in his spare time?
