2023: the year biodiversity’s green shoots finally blossom?

By Cameron McAllister

With the rapid pace of change required to fight biodiversity loss, each passing year is of the utmost importance. In 2022 we witnessed a sea change in how the world’s governments talked about biodiversity, will the world now act, allowing us to witness actual positive changes in the sea and on land in 2023?

COP15, the latest conference for nations that are party to the UN Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD), provided a shock in December by not being a complete waste of time: nearly all the world’s countries signed up to a historic, ‘sweeping’ deal to safeguard the planet’s biodiversity.

The agreement – the Kunming-Montreal global biodiversity framework (GBF) – included a key, if controversial, ‘30×30’ pledge to protect 30% of the world’s land and sea, “especially areas of particular importance for biodiversity”, by 2030.

The goal is controversial for many reasons. In particular, as Durham’s Prof Harriet Bulkeley wrote in The Conversation prior to the finalising of the COP15 deal, there were worries that such a target risked trying to “boost wildlife by expelling people and erecting walls to keep them out”.

These fears have been tempered by the final text of the target containing a call for “respecting the rights of indigenous peoples and local communities, including over their traditional territories”.

The success of COP15 shows the world’s governments united against biodiversity loss heading in to 2023

Indigenous peoples and local communities (IPLCs) are involved in the CBD process via the International Indigenous Forum on Biodiversity (IIFB), which celebrated the “timely recognition of Indigenous Peoples and local community contributions, roles, rights and responsibilities to Mother Earth” in the agreement.

The main message on the COP15 agreement from the IIFB was, “We have spoken and you have heard us, let us now put those words into action”. The lack of effective implementation, failing to put words into action, was a major factor in the failings of the 2010 Aichi targets, none of which were fully realised. Viviana Figueroa, a representative of the IIFB, raised the critical question with Carbon Brief: “How will parties make sure these targets will be achieved?”.

The answer is that there will be a monitoring mechanism to assess progress towards targets at the national and international levels. National strategies will be revised to meet the GBF goals, nations will report on indicators included in the GBF, and there will then be global reviews of national strategies and collective international progress.

The results of these global reviews will then be used to urge nations to “ratchet” up their initial ambitions, in a similar process to the implementation of the Paris Agreement which is often referred to as “present, review, ratchet”. It’s not perfect – the GBF and its associated documents are not legally binding – but it’s an important step.

An earlier draft of the agreement also called for “mandatory monitoring, assessment and disclosure” of businesses’ impacts on biodiversity, in addition to governments’ reports. The call for voluntary monitoring included in the final text does though still send a powerful signal to industry that any negative effects on biodiversity will need to be reduced in time, Andrew Deutz, an environmental law and finance specialist, told Nature.

The US is the only UN member state not to have ratified the CDB

The success of COP15 shows almost all the world’s governments united against biodiversity loss heading into 2023. Only two countries are not a party to the CDB, one perhaps a little more important than the other: the Holy See (about the same size as all the woodland owned by Durham University) and the USA (a megadiverse country the size of Europe, which happens to have the largest economy in the world). The Holy See is not a UN member, while the US is the only UN member state not to have ratified the CDB.

President Biden has however signed an executive order to protect 30% of the USA’s land and sea. Whether a Republican-controlled House of Representatives will pass legislation towards that aim remains to be seen – it’s Republicans in the senate who have blocked ratification of the CBD.

Closer to home, in 2020/2021, £464 million of public sector funding was provided for biodiversity in England (biodiversity is a devolved issue in the UK). This is equivalent to around just 0.02% of GDP, with even less money provided by the UK for international biodiversity efforts. Domestic and international biodiversity funding have both suffered a sustained short-term decline since 2015/16.

If the UK, one of the world’s most nature-depleted countries, is to meet the GBF’s commitments more funding and better targets will be required.

The UK’s targets for species decline – snuck out just before Christmas, long after the October deadline set in the Environment Act – sound promising, including halting the decline in species populations by 2030. However, they were met with disappointment and dismay by charities like the RSPB and the Wildlife Trusts for allowing species decline to continue until 2030 and only aiming for a 10% increase on 2030 levels by 2042.

“Simply aiming for slightly more nature in 20 years’ time than our current, the extremely depleted state is far from world-leading, and an abdication of our responsibility to future generations,” Craig Bennett, chief executive of the Wildlife Trusts, told the BBC.

The world took a large step in fighting the biodiversity crisis in 2022 by agreeing to COP15’s GBF. However, the UK – whose government claimed to be leading a coalition of high-ambition countries during COP15 – pushing forward with such low-ambition targets is not a promising omen for the fight against biodiversity in 2023.

Image: @VonWong – Extinction Thermometer