Hypnagogia: has science found the key to creativity?

By Cameron McAllister

I check my watch: 3:01 PM. I stand up, close my curtains, and turn off my light. I go back to my desk, take the keys out of my pocket and grip them firmly at the end of a loose arm, leaning back in my chair, shuffling it slightly; I need to make sure that when I let go the keys are aligned directly above the plate that I’ve positioned on the floor, upside-down. I hope it doesn’t break. I’m about to open my mind and dive into the cavernous depths of my subconscious. And no, I haven’t taken any drugs.

***

The drowsiness inspired by a difficult maths problem might not seem helpful, but it could in fact be a hint from your body. A recent study has shown that entering the initial stages of sleep before being woken up can help people to gain insight into tricky problems.

This stage of sleep, hypnagogia or N1, is the transitional stage of consciousness that occurs between wake and sleep. It’s the daydream on a long train journey that suddenly becomes vivid and real and gains a life of its own as sleep starts to overcome you. The thoughts, once coherent, that start to sway and slalom and swivel until you wake up the next morning, the night’s dreams slowly evaporating with the morning dew.

Study participants were given the problem of manipulating eight-digit number sequences by applying two specific rules to reach a set answer. Unbeknownst to them, a simple approach would lead to the correct answer in all cases.

During the study, the 84 per cent that had yet to solve the problem were given a 20-minute break and encouraged to take a nap. To avoid falling into a deeper stage of sleep participants were asked to hold a bottle, so if they fell asleep they would drop it and be woken by the sound.

They were then faced with the problem again. 83 per cent of those that reached hypnagogia without descending into a deeper sleep found the secret shortcut to solve the problem compared to 31 per cent of people who stayed completely awake and 14 per cent of those who slept more deeply.

The study, led by Delphine Oudliette of Paris’s National Institute of Health and Medical Research, is important evidence of the potent power of the special in-between state of hypnagogia. However, tales of its power have long abounded in the worlds of art, religion and even science.

There are even tantalising hints that some biblical revelations may have come from this altered state

The Spanish surrealist artist Salvador Dalí called hypnagogia ‘the slumber with a key’ and noted the importance of ‘sleeping without sleeping’; in place of a bottle, he held a heavy key above an upside-down plate. It’s not hard to see how Dalí’s imagery might have been informed by these brief sojourns into his subconscious.

There are even tantalising hints that some biblical revelations may have come from this altered state. The Hebrew book Samuel tells of how Samuel hears the voice of God calling his name while laying down to sleep. Hearing one’s name being called while drifting off is a common hypnagogic hallucination. The book then recounts how Samuel receives a long and complex monologue from God, concerning the punishment of Samuel’s elderly priest. While many prophets were accused of madness by their peers, or in re-evaluations by some modern scholars, the more relatable story of Samuel has, according to Durham’s Emeritus Professor Christopher C. H. Cook, mainly escaped such criticism.

While hypnagogia is a normal part of the transition from consciousness to sleep, it has traditionally been studied in relation to the sleep disorder narcolepsy, in which an inability to separate dreams and the waking world can lead to horrifying hallucinations. Edgar Allen Poe, much of whose work could reasonably be described by the phrase ‘horrifying hallucinations’, spoke fondly of the “fancies [of] exquisite delicacy” that came to him “at those mere points of time where the confines of the waking world blend with those of the world of dreams”.

***

I hear the sound of the keys hitting the plate in reverse, after I have already woken, like hearing the “bang!” of a firework after seeing it light up the sky. It was my hand losing grip that reminded me not to fall off the edge into full sleep. I turn the light on, open my laptop back up and get to work. I’m working on a coding problem related to efficiently calculating the volume of cavities within a protein.

***

Science, coding, and maths might not be what you first expect when you think of ‘creativity’. A surrealist artist tapping into their subconscious seems a much more natural use of hypnagogia. But while we are often taught set formulations to solve problems, finding something new — a new link, a new hypothesis, a new conceptual approach – relies on inventiveness. Did reaching hypnagogia help me with my biophysics problem? Well, perhaps: I had some new ideas for how to approach the problem but struggled (slightly drowsily) to implement them. Maybe entering hypnagogia – like science, and like art – requires more practise.

Image: composite, adapted from Distinct Mind and Vladislav Muslakov images by Cameron McAllister