“There’s only one Iceland … there must be something special there”

By Cameron McAllister

Icelandia may sound like a far-off fairy tale realm, but it could in fact be something even more outlandish: a huge hidden continent located in Iceland and the surrounding ocean.

Durham’s Professor Gillian Foulger has led an international team of experts that believe they have found evidence for Icelandia, which at around 600,000 km2 would be over twice the size of the UK.

The prevailing theory, the mantle plume hypothesis, posits that Iceland is built of and surrounded by oceanic crust, but Prof Foulger believes that multiple geological findings do not support this assertion.

For example, the crust under Iceland is over 40 km thick — seven times thicker than normal oceanic crust.

In the mantle plume theory, there is thought to be an upswelling of hot rock thousands of kilometres beneath Iceland: the mantle plume. This plume erupts, sometimes literally, on the surface as the Iceland hotspot, the region of high volcanic activity on and around the island of Iceland.

Prof Foulger decided to test this hypothesis. “I put out an array of seismic stations all over Iceland, about 400 kilometres wide,” she explains. But the data was not as expected, “I gathered evidence that suggested that the [geological] feature underneath Iceland, that we all assumed was a mantle plume, just stopped at about 400 kilometres [depth].”

“A mantle plume is supposed to start at the Earth’s core, to rise up like a mushroom a full 3,000 kilometres from bottom to top.” Clearly something was amiss. While her initial instinct was to agree with everyone else that “the Iceland mantle plume is a little bit different”, a chance encounter at an international conference started to change her mind.

“I go to an international conference with this message [of Iceland’s unusual mantle plume] and a very eminent earth scientist came to look at my poster and he said, ‘maybe there isn’t a plume’”.

Despite initial reservations (her first thought was, “Are you completely bonkers?”), the idea that scientists could have Iceland’s mantle plume all wrong piqued Prof Foulger’s interest.

“I said, ‘well what’s causing Iceland then?’, and he suggested his idea, so I asked another question, another question, and after 10 years of asking questions I finally convinced myself that he was right.” A microcosm of the scientific process in action.

Well, what is causing Iceland? First, it’s important to note that, as Prof Foulger puts it, “there’s only one Iceland in the world”. “It’s not a common thing; there must be something special there.” It was this intuition that fuelled her research.

Helpfully, Prof Foulger already had an idea of Iceland — ironically thanks to the sexism of British science. “Right at the beginning of my career I graduated with a good degree in geology, then I got the master’s degree in geophysics and from the first four jobs that I applied for I was told women aren’t allowed to apply”.

It was like somebody had kind of thrown a window open in a dark room and the sun had poured in

But in Iceland, while not perfect, the situation was somewhat better: “I was actually offered an interesting sounding job there!”. So, she learned Icelandic and “made Iceland [her] career”. Hence, she already knew a lot about Iceland “from all sorts of different points of view”. Yet despite everything, there was never a satisfactory answer for the fundamental question of “why Iceland was there”.

Then, about ten years ago, a consulting contract with a generous purse came up (“sort of ‘you can spend what you like, do what you like’”). Prof Foulger put the money she made into a research fund at Durham University, giving her the freedom to choose an interesting research project. The choice was obvious: Iceland and its mysterious ‘mantle plume’.

The first step was to compile a think tank of all the “top experts, the most lateral thinkers, the most sceptical people, the biggest question askers, and the people with the deepest knowledge of every single aspect of the whole North Atlantic Ocean [where Iceland is situated]”.

They gathered at St. Chad’s College, ideal for being “sort of isolated away from anything, [with] no distractions”, and brainstormed ideas. There were four meetings, each three days long. “We just came up with this sort of amazing idea.”

Though it wasn’t until the end of the third meeting, while finishing up and thanking the attendants, that Prof Foulger realised how revolutionary the “amazing idea” was. “All of a sudden, one of the French guys, Laurent Geoffroy [Professor, Université de Bretagne Occidentale], just burst out: ‘Gillian, we’re going to suggest there’s continental crust under there!’”.

“It was like somebody had kind of thrown a window open in a dark room and the sun had poured in… I suddenly realised that this was kind of a complete opposite of what everybody had thought up to then.”

People talk about plate tectonics, and they assume it’s going to break like a dinnerplate into two, but it’s more like pizza

You may have learned about continental drift in school. The basic idea is that convection currents of hot molten material in the Earth’s mantle cause the planet’s tectonic plates to move. The movement is subtle, just a few centimetres per year, but over millions of years this can add up to massive changes.

Plates moving towards each other can cause mountains, volcanoes, and earthquakes. Alternatively, as plates move apart from each other magma rises to fill the gap before cooling and forming new rock. “So as the continents move apart you get this new crust formed by rising magma”.

Iceland lies on the Mid-Atlantic Ridge, between the North American and Eurasian tectonic plates, which are moving apart. The mantle plume would be “delivering the extra magma” that has formed Iceland.

But this classic idea of plate tectonics is what wrongly predicts Iceland to have a thin, young crust — something Prof Foulger and her team had already disproved. It also can’t explain the density of the crust, the variations in crust thickness, or the specific pattern of volcanism. “You couldn’t explain many other observations if we assume that.”

What else could be going on? “The continents break up, you get this volcanic crust forming as they move apart […] and what happens initially is that if we look at a cross-section of the continent it doesn’t just break into two with new crust forming in the middle, but it sort of stretches and it thins.”

Iceland is well known as an idyllic holiday destination, home to hot springs and beautifully rugged mountains. According to Prof Foulger, it may also be the cheese of a giant continental crust pizza.

“People talk about plate tectonics, and they assume it’s going to break like a dinnerplate into two, but it’s more like pizza.”

“If you pull a pizza apart from the sides some of it will tear and break, but then you’ll get stretchy bits. Iceland basically has formed where there was a stretchy bit. And it’s always been known that this stretchy bit was there.”

“Where the continent broke up to form Iceland, there’s a geological structure that goes right across that stretches [across]. You can see it in Scotland and in West Greenland.” When the Eurasian and North American continental plates were connected “this sort of stretchy geological structure was one.”

“As the continents moved apart it basically sort of stretched and the volcanism broke south of Iceland and north of Iceland.” But in the middle this geological mozzarella stretched as the plates pulled apart.

“South of Iceland and north of Iceland, the volcanic material rose up and formed new ocean crust, but in Iceland itself it just erupted through the continental crust and sort of formed a layer on the top, like icing on a cake”.

Or, to strain the original metaphor to its absolute limits, the volcanic material was like the tomato sauce on a freshly baked pizza bubbling up through the Icelandic cheese to form what we now know as Iceland. “Meanwhile, the stuff underneath just gradually stretched”.

This is not a totally new crazy wacky idea

While the idea is an innovative departure from previous theories, Prof Foulger is keen to stress that it is not without precedent. “This is not a totally new crazy wacky idea, it’s known that this happened along the margins of the Northeast Atlantic, it just wasn’t so long”.

“Norway has lots of oil and gas, and they mined this from their waters offshore.” “These regions that they’re taking all those hydrocarbons out of [are] basically stretched continental crust which is subsided under the ocean”.

This is one of the important implications of the research. Coastal states can, under certain conditions, gain exclusive rights to the minerals of the adjoining seabed if the submerged area is found to be part of the same continental landmass as the country. Just like in the case of Norway’s coast, these regions of submerged continental crust can also be very rich in resources.

“All we’re really saying is that instead of being say, 200 kilometres wide along the edges of the oceans, it’s much wider at Iceland […] and it stretched right across the Atlantic”.

In other words, continental crust is already known to stretch, the suggestion is that it is more of a super-stretchy Gouda than a Cheddar. But if that’s true, wouldn’t there be many more examples of regions of submerged continental crusts around the world that haven’t been lucky enough to peak above the ocean?

It turns out there are many such regions. The Mascarene Plateau east of Africa and a huge area around New Zealand known as ‘Zealandia’ are two examples. Even the area surrounding Tristan de Cunha in the South Atlantic, the most remote inhabited archipelago in the world, is thought to be submerged continental crust.

The next step for Prof Foulger and her collaborators is to conclusively prove the existence of Icelandia, work which has been slowed by Covid-19 restrictions but should soon be able to begin. The impact on Earth sciences could be profound. Maybe one day geography textbooks will be teaching the students of the future Foulger’s theory of the tectonic pizza.

Image: Cameron McAllister with VQGAN+CLIP