‘Give it up for your home team!’ – The Durham Revue take on Oxford and Cambridge at this year’s Comedyfest
‘This year for Lent, I’m giving up punch lines’ was the witty one-liner from Durham’s Elgan Evan Alderman, but Sunday’s Comedyfest was certainly not deficient in gags. The Cambridge Footlights and The Oxford Revue joined The Durham Revue for a night of sketch comedy. Billed as three of the nation’s best student comedy groups performing in one evening, the show carried a certain weight of expectation and the buzz generated in the Gala Theatre before the start of the show was palpable.
Cambridge
Cambridge opened the evening with a confident three-man show. Setting the tone with a conversational introduction, Ben, Dom and Ryan managed to tread the line between peacocking and self-deprecating with considerable charm.
The ‘Ryan gets an orgasm every time he hears applause’ gag instilled a recognisably male student vibe, but as their set developed the trio displayed a wide range of humour.
As a fan of wordplay, I especially enjoyed their restaurant sketch in which concepts such as ‘disappointment’ and ‘ominous foreboding’ were served instead of food. Sketches such as these revealed comic ingenuity and another particular favourite was a 1990s sales pitch for emoticons.
More gems included a wonderfully articulate parrot and a pair of endearing snails. Blending together wacky concepts with identifiably truthful characterisation proved a winning combination for the charismatic trio.
I can only recall one sketch, set in a urinal, which fell flat in their whole set. If I had to be pernickety, certain lines were slightly muffled and so could have been delivered with more volume, but overall the Footlights delivered a highly impressive and professional performance.
Oxford
The Oxford Revue opened with a risky gimmick that, sadly, didn’t pay off. It was announced that past alumni Stewart Lee and Michael Palin would be performing; only of course they didn’t show up and it was left to the floundering troupe to apologise. I didn’t feel there was anything particularly clever, funny or original in this conceit and it seemed to drag, creating an uninspiring opening.
However, from thereon in, the set improved with particularly lively and engaging performances from George Mather and Will Truefitt. Mather nailed the creepy physicality and facial expressions of a David Attenborough-esque convenience store stalker.
For me though, Oxford’s best material emerged when reliance on crude language and wacky performances were discarded in favour of developed ideas such as the idiom-saturated English language test that anyone who had experienced a language GCSE oral exam (which was most people in the audience) could relate to.
Competing with this sketch for the biggest laugh was the hospital sketch in which doctors fought to nurse a dying joke. The comic self-consciousness was enjoyable. In all, The Oxford Revue provided a scattering of gems in amongst some less original material.
Durham
After the short interval, it was Durham’s turn and they could not have been bolder with their opening. Starting their set with ‘Eye of the Tiger’ and voicing over with the words ‘Give it up for your home team!’ unashamedly drew attention to the rivalry between the groups and was lapped up by the audience, who responded enthusiastically.
This energy can only have assisted The Durham Revue as they proceeded to deliver a highly polished and consistent performance during their hour long set.
All seven performers – Sam Kennerley, Simon Gallow, Megan Brownrigg, Stefanie Jones, Tilly Dawson, Elgan Evan Alderman and Sam Harper-Booth – demonstrated impressive acting ability and comic brilliance. It is to their credit that I find it hard to single any one out.
The range of characters provided a blend of subtle and eccentric performances and Alderman’s dead pan expressions provided a refreshingly caustic tone to what I had generally felt to be a little on the trying-too-hard side in the other comedy groups.
All seven members were put to use in a pleasing variety of combinations with a mix of developed set pieces and punchier gags. The longer performance time allocated to The Durham Revue allowed the group to develop a theme or set of repeated ideas for comic effect such as a bizarrely hysterical repetition of Kennerley’s ‘Boris’ character.
In terms of material, Durham pushed the boat out furthest, daring the audience to laugh by alluding to topical news stories such as Oscar Pistorius, the horse meat scandal and even the priest child abuse scandal.
They displayed impressive writing skills in the way in which they joked about religion whilst avoiding being patronising or offensive, but more importantly whilst being genuinely funny. Ideas for making religion more accessible included ‘Qur’an Qur’an’ and ‘Torah the explorer’. My appetite for wordplay was again more than sated by sketches of quick-fire puns between Jones and Alderman.
Though on their own they would not have been enough to hide any shortcomings, simple things like well-chosen track interludes and smart attire gave The Durham Revue a certain slickness and professionalism that allowed the audience to completely relax whilst watching them perform. Such attention to detail must be given credit.
If anything could have been improved I think that certain sketches could have been developed further or given a more satisfying ending as a couple felt as though they had been cut a little short.
Though they may have had the advantage of longer performance time, Durham clearly excelled in this year’s Comedyfest. I can’t wait for next year!

