Sport in schools: competition is healthy and necessary

by Tom Dimaio
In the aftermath of London 2012, a debate has arisen as to whether competitive sport in schools is key to securing an Olympic legacy. It has also been suggested that this competitive edge is lacking in state schools.
This debate gives rise to two separate questions. Why does the private sector consistently outdo the state with regards to sport? The second question concerns the competitive nature of this sport: has the growing nanny-state left us fearing the damage that competition can do to our children at a young age?
Firstly, the criticisms levelled at state schools are a huge generalisation. There are many state schools that have a high level of sporting success. Despite this, it must be said that with regards to sport, the private side of education has always had the upper hand.
There are of course numerous reasons for the private school dominance of competitive sport. The most obvious of these is the issue of funding. However, this does not appear to be the most important reason.
Sport at a private school is taken seriously. Playing for your school team is a matter of pride, a pride that is instilled within you at a young age. This pride is also present in the students of state schools, but from my experience, it has different allegiances.
Experience has shown me that those whose schooling is left to the state show far less pride and commitment to the school they attend. Instead they seek out a local club at which to play their sport.
My school lacked a decent football, tennis and hockey club. Does this therefore mean I did not partake in these sports? Of course not. It is important for today’s politicians who fear for the Olympic legacy to remember that opportunities for sport lay far beyond the school gates and in my opinion, quite rightly.
This does not mean that competitive sport doesn’t have a place in the state sector, of course it does. Private schools dedicate a far larger portion of their curriculum to sport, which is certainly a good thing. State schools could learn a lot from the private sector with regards to the mentality they take towards sport.
Looking at the issue of competition, the debate appears completely baffling. Some parents certainly feel that the despair felt by their kids at school after suffering defeat can be truly distressing, but is this really true? I’ve heard stories of schools stopping competitive school sports days, as they were unfair on the losers. This is surely an example of over-sensitivity. Losing in a school sports day isn’t a life-altering event, it isn’t even a week altering event. I seriously doubt that many children are particularly upset after missing out on the prize.
Winning on the other hand comes with a host of benefits. Watching a young child win a race or score a goal is quite the spectacle. Every goal is a World Cup winner; every line crossed is a 100-metre final – surely this level of ecstasy shouldn’t be taken away from the youngest generations.
Along with the thrill of winning comes a lust for further glory. The knowledge that you are the best, even for a brief moment brings with it the urge to do more, to take your talent to the next level.
For me that’s where the heart of the debate lies. If we are tasked with creating gold medallists from the future, sport at school needs to be competitive. If children aren’t given a chance to be winners at an early age, they’ll never get that feeling of wanting to win.
