Sport in schools: a fear of fierce competition?

Former cabinet politician Alan Milburn says that fee-paying pupils benefit from an emphasis on “soft skills” such as teamwork and communication, conveyed through sport, music and drama. With more pupils now getting the academic grades needed for university, private pupils benefit because of their more rounded CVs and eloquent presentation. This, naturally, is supported by an ethos which inspires the winning spirit in every student, placing a strong emphasis on competitive sport as “a positive influence on every pupil”. They shout from the rooftops that success on the playing field is concurrent with a successful future developing leadership, teamwork and social skills. It is then no surprise that universities such as Durham, Oxford and Exeter (highly populated by private school alumni) are considered among the best for sports.
Conversely, in state schools, the ideal of being the best through fair but tough competition is condemned at being unjust, creating a social disparity between those who are “winners” or “losers”. Highlighted by the low proportion of state school students who apply to Oxbridge, these students are not steered towards being exceptional in any area; instead this is replaced with a comparatively less rigid – and less ambitious – aim of improving the pupil’s self-esteem. The silver lining is that at least they can burn off any morsel of what was left of their Tesco’s Meal Deal lunch. State school education lacks is the encouragement of students to shine and this is filtered through in their reluctant attitude towards competitive sport. Instead, complacently falling back on mediocrity will do.
It is also worth noting the class divide that is inherent in many sporting games. In last year’s Olympics, athletics, diving and sailing were highly dominated by a private school population, while rowing, shooting and equestrian sports traditionally have middle to upper class connotations. Commentators may reprove this but let’s face it – the notion of a state school in inner London offering horse riding and clay shooting to its pupils seems somewhat absurd.
It appears more sensible them to settle for football, more fitting with working class origins. Frank Lampard and Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain were the only privately-schooled players in England’s recent 21-man squad against Brazil earlier this month. Yet with the rising affluence of many football players it will probably be the case that those sons following in their fathers’ footsteps will come from private schools. Eventually we will see that even those sports habitually dominated by those who are less than wealthy will be marred by a proportionately larger middle class population; a monopoly of sport by the privately educated.
To get into the practicalities of this matter, it will always hold true that the facilities provided in private schools are infinitely greater; North London’s private Harrow School boasts two all-weather multi-sport pitches, an indoor climbing wall, a weights room, a swimming pool and a sports hall. There are courts for tennis, rackets, squash and fives. It has its own golf course. If, then, private funding allows for facilities which will enable students to physically achieve their best, publicly financed state schools will get the short end of the stick.
Perhaps all this jargon about equality and self-esteem is used to cover the fact that a vast lack of state school funding has fabricated apathetic, uncompetitive alumni who will not push themselves to the boundaries of victory; yet another shortcoming of the state system.
