Rihanna’s mosque photos are a cynical publicity stunt

By Francesca Moll, responding to Ellie de la Bedoyere on the subject of Rihanna’s photographs outside the The Sheikh Zayed Grand in Abu Dhabi. Read the original article here. 

To join the debate, email us with your angle. If you feel passionately about this topic, then enter our Comment Competition for the chance to win book vouchers and your name in print.

It’s quite an uncanny experience when someone replies to one of your Comment articles. It’s happened to me before. You can feel a little under attack. So I just want to reassure the writer of the original article that, honestly, it’s nothing personal.

Nevertheless, there were so many things about her recent article on Rihanna’s photoshoot in an Abu Dhabi mosque that I found deeply, deeply frustrating.

Maybe it was the constant reference to “political correctness” that automatically got my heckles up. I can’t help but feel that people throw around that term far too indiscriminately whenever a particularly raw issue in modern society comes up.800px-Sheikh_Zayed_Grand_Mosque

What are you actually saying, when you demonize the ‘PC brigade’? That a certain group of people take a different view to you, and therefore are shutting down ‘freedom of speech’ and ‘free thought’? Well, I’d like to suggest a different viewpoint, if I may:

So-called ‘political correctness’ isn’t a massive liberal conspiracy to shut everyone else up. What you perceive as such is simply, to quote Caitlin Moran, “formalising politeness.” And in fact, by tarring with the same derogatory brush and attempts to make sure that all cultures, genders and sexual orientations are treated with respect, it is you who are shutting down further productive discussion. By all means disagree with the broad liberal consensus on the issue. But for the love of whatever equally respect-worthy belief system you subscribe to, let’s move away from the Daily Mail style rhetoric.

To be honest, I’ll agree with the original writer that Rihanna’s clothing and poses weren’t particularly sexually provocative, certainly not by the standards of much of Western media at the moment. But this rather misses the point. The issue I have with Rihanna’s actions is summed up rather nicely in this sentence of the original article: “Or is it actually very appropriate – a striking, strong woman dressed in hijab, embracing her beauty and independence in a Muslim way and giving the magnificence of Muslim culture its rightful recognition in the public sphere.”

But Rihanna isn’t a Muslim woman. Nor am I. Nor is the writer of the article, or so I assume from the fact she didn’t mention it at any stage. If I am wrong, I sincerely apologise.

what on earth would give Rihanna the right to represent all Muslim women, simply by virtue of barging into a sacred place uninvited and donning some token headgear?

So what on earth would give Rihanna the right to represent all Muslim women, simply by virtue of barging into a sacred place uninvited and donning some token headgear, even supposing that was indeed her intent? And what gives someone writing from the safe distance of Durham the right to judge whether her actions were or were not respectful towards a culture that she does not belong to?

Rihanna’s actions aren’t a big middle finger up at women’s oppression in the Middle East, and it doesn’t require provocative sexual posturing or bared flesh to be offensive. The reason people are angry is because Rihanna is exploiting a culture she doesn’t belong to without even asking permission, for some sort of dubious promotional purpose. If you wanted to celebrate Islamic culture and Muslim women, surely one would choose a Muslim woman to represent it – or at least consult one. And that’s not political correctness. That’s just common courtesy.

Even the original writer acknowledges that Rihanna is hardly a daring crusader for greater cultural understanding: “of course she’s exploiting this beautiful religious centre to create a beautiful picture” she remarks. I’m going to go a bit further with that: Rihanna’s little photo shoot– like Robin Thicke’s Blurred Lines video or Lady Gaga’s charming song “burqa”- is simply another popstar cynically tapping into a live political issue to drum up publicity.

Let’s be very clear here – because unnuanced rhetoric has helped nobody on this issue – a cultural triumph is Beethoven’s ninth symphony; the works of Shakespeare; indeed, that beautiful mosque that a certain singer reduced to little more than her private studio. What Rihanna achieved that day, on the other hand, was a deliberate courting of controversy, because she knew it would attract attention. Which, if it is not too uncharitable to say it, is what I rather suspect the original writer was trying to do.

Photograph: Marvan032