Your Tinder fiasco doesn’t justify an age change
Issy Rush
Tinder: arguably the epitome of procrastination topped with an occasional ego boost. And, for the most of us, it ends there. Yet for one Dutch man, Tinder matches, or seemingly a lack of, have led to the decision to identify as 20 years younger. Legally.
Emile Ratelband, a 69-year-old from Holland, has gone to court to change his birth date from 11 March 1949 to 11 March 1969, in order to become, as he puts it, his true “emotional age”. Having been denied the right to legally change his age on his documents by local authorities, his response of suing these authorities has sparked much outrage.
Ratelband’s reasoning? Not enough young women are ‘swiping right’ on his Tinder profile. In comparison to simply improving your bio or reducing the number of snapchat-filtered selfies on your profile, Ratelband’s response to his dismal numbers of matches does seem a little drastic. However, once we surpass the trivial aspects of this out-of-the-ordinary headline, we are met with the much more chilling implications of what might happen if his bid is actually successful. In particular, how would this change the laws relating to paedophilia? If it were legally possible to change your age, what is there to stop a 47-year-old from ‘identifying’ as a 17-year-old in order to groom young teenagers, and legally get away with it? Moreover, if one could identify as younger, the same rules ought to apply to a person wishing to identify as older. Suddenly, the business of fake-IDs seems to have gone bust.

That is not to say that nothing positive has emerged from this debate. Indeed, it has brought to light the issue of age discrimination and in doing so, Ratelband has given the elderly what they often lack: a voice. It is undoubtable that the elderly are often dismissed as incapable, whilst the youth are seen to be tirelessly conscientious. And yet both of these assumptions are often entirely unfounded. I need only compare my 80-year-old grandmother, whose domineering nature has a whole village wrapped around her little finger at home, to my 19-year-old housemate who has not changed out of his Hugh Hefner- style dressing gown for a week.
However, it is unfounded that “nowhere are you so discriminated against as with your age”, as Ratelband has claimed to Dutch newspaper De Telegraaf, especially when one considers that Ratelband has compared his plight to that of the transgender community. It is undeniable that transgender people face much more discrimination than the elderly, and to a greater extent. As Marjolein van den Brink, a human rights and gender issues specialist, put it: whilst the elderly are wrongly discriminated against with regards to employment, this is “just one element” of your life and only occurs towards the end of it, whereas gender “follows you from birth to grave, and it determines nearly everything”. Thus, it is understandable that Ratelband’s justification that “we live in a time when you can […] change your gender, why can’t I decide my own age?” has caused considerable offence. By placing gender fluidity on par with ‘age fluidity’, Ratelband has belittled the trans community and undermined the struggles and stigma that they have and do endure.
It seems to me that Ratelband ought to accept the natural process of ageing. Yes, it is scary – I know people who have already found grey hairs at even our tender age (!) – but it is inevitable. Perhaps all we need is a change in attitude.
Images by Marcia Pervey via Flickr and Benson Schliesser via Flickr
