Did you check your underwear before you left this morning? Turns out that’s ‘consent’
Ellie Bagley
Consent: only two syllables but defined so differently to many people. The word alone raises many issues – what counts as consent being the main question around the matter. I can, however, certainly say that the type of underwear worn by a woman does not equate even in the slightest to consent.
Recently, in Ireland, a 27-year-old man was acquitted of rape and one of the defence’s pieces of evidence was none other than the underwear the victim was wearing at the time of the incident. The underwear was described as “a thong with a lacy front”. Whilst showing the court the underwear, Elizabeth O’Connell (the defence) stated: “Does the evidence out rule the possibility that she was attracted to the defendant and was open to meeting someone and being with someone? You have to look at the way she was dressed. She was wearing a thong with a lacy front.”. For someone to have their underwear shown publicly is embarrassing enough, but in a court?
Wear what you want – you’re not making yourself more vulnerable to predators.
I can say, from personal experience, that as a victim you constantly blame yourself; look for every little detail of the events leading up to the incident. You convince yourself it was something you did that made them think it was OK. It’s not OK – it’s never OK unless the person explicitly, through words, consents.

I dread to think what the victim felt like. Innocent until proven guilty – yes, but the fact that the underwear was even mentioned is absolutely absurd. A woman should be able to dress as she pleases, as ‘provocatively’ as she likes. Dressing in this way should not make a man think it is fine for him to assume consent. Consent should never be assumed. Women are people, with feelings and opinions and rights, and clothes should, quite frankly, never be a defining factor.
The response of Ireland to this has involved protests and the trending of “#thisisnotconsent”, with women attaching photos of their underwear to express their solidarity and support in the fact that how a woman dresses is not consent.
Women have also shown up to the protests in their underwear, including a woman named Stacie Ellen Murphy, who also wrote upon herself statements such as “no consent” and “I’m not asking for it”. This is a very strong message which I totally agree with – but the fact that a woman has had to physically write this on herself to make it known is very upsetting. TD Ruth Coppinger also addressed it in Irish Parliament by producing a thong in the Dail chambers saying: “It might seem embarrassing to show a pair of thongs in here in this incongruous setting, but… how do you think a rape victim or a woman feels at the incongruous setting of her underwear being shown in a court?” – I could not have said it better myself.
This should be addressed, and very well known. If you’re a woman (or man) out there, wear what you want – you’re not making yourself more vulnerable to predators. And if anyone is to actually believe that, their ignorance is showing. Clothing should never be brought up as evidence in a rape trial. It is never the victim’s fault.
If you have been affected by any of the issues raised in this article the following University organisations may be of help: Durham Nightline, whose number can be found on the back of your campus card or on DUO.
Images by John Bauld via Flickr and Geralt via Pixabay
