Your Party: handing Reform UK a landslide victory?
By Sophie Dawson
Wealth tax, free healthcare, clean energy, and a free Palestine. Synonymous policies, championed by two distinct parties, indistinguishable in all but name. Calls to merge: dismissed. Accusations of vote-splitting: overlooked. Is there truly a space on the political spectrum for both the Greens and Your Party?
Without flattening all hope of Reform UK’s imminent downfall, the last time an explicitly socialist party won power in Britain was in 1945. The most progressive platform following the Atlee Government, led by Michael Foot in 1983, was termed ‘the longest suicide note in history’. In 2019, Labour suffered the worst electoral defeat since 1935 under the most left-wing leader in recent history, Corbyn. So, the odds aren’t exactly in our favour. To make matters worse? The majoritarian, first-past-the-post system, favouring parties with geographically concentrated support, exacerbating the disproportionate ‘bonus’ enjoyed by winners. It seems, though, as disillusionment rises, that we might finally have a chance. February’s by-election in Gorton and Denton, witnessing the victory of Green Party candidate, Hannah Spencer, symbolises the dawn of a new kind of politics. It reflects the two-party system’s demise. Tactical voting is out of fashion. Hope is building. Yet, with 4,000 votes separating Spencer from Reform’s Matt Goodwin, Your Party’s participation would have gifted Farage a ninth seat in Parliament on a silver platter. It is high time for the left to unite.
The one thing Corbyn has in common with Margaret Thatcher? He’s like marmite. From hijacking Theresa May’s Facebook Live, to promising free university tuition, his ascension to the Labour Party leadership produced a ‘youthquake’ turnout in 2017, securing 60% of the aged 18-24 vote. In 2019, however, his popularity plummeted. His position on Brexit was unclear. His character was stained by smear campaigns, citing anti-Semitic activity and ‘terrorist sympathies’, the effects of which he has never quite managed to shake. He lost stronghold ‘Red Wall’ seats. He was suspended by Starmer. Anticipated to assume Your Party’s leadership, will Corbyn forever be haunted by his turbulent political past? Has he become part of Parliament’s furniture, too worn to attract any significant number of new voters, or too despised for many to even contemplate his policies? Or, is his triumph over Zarah Sultana a blessing in disguise: is this country, considering the recent proliferation of morally reprehensible, anti-immigrant rhetoric, too racist to vote for a woman of Pakistani heritage?
The one thing Corbyn has in common with Margaret Thatcher? He’s like marmite.
Enter Zack Polanski. A skilful public speaker, with an impressive debate record, Green Party membership climbed from 60,000 to almost 200,000 following his election as leader. Is a fresh face exactly what is needed to haul the left back to a state of legitimacy ensuing Your Party’s self-implosion? Is it time for Corbyn, notwithstanding his monumental efforts to advance socialism, to take a back seat?
Seeking to extinguish blame for fragmenting the left vote, Sultana advocated for dual party membership, a pledge which seems, though ideal in a perfectly functioning democracy, counterintuitive. It would reduce Your Party to the role of a pressure group, haemorrhaging support to the Greens, or wreak further division amongst the left, encouraging tighter partnership over any issue but electoral ones. It is improbable that either party will secure a sufficient vote share to invite the other to form a coalition, relegating both, once again, to the opposition’s backbenches.
It begs the question: was Your Party doomed from the beginning? Plagued by internal disputes, it lacked a cohesive ideology amongst founding figures. It resembled, in the view of Sultana, a ‘sexist boys’ club’, leaving Corbyn’s reputation as an egalitarian in tatters. It reinforced age-long perceptions of the left as divided, disorderly, and implied its inability to pose an effective challenge to Reform UK. A Reform government is a threat. It is not an inevitability. Certainly, in a fully operational democracy, pluralism is desirable. However, in a situation where, as described by Sultana, the choice is between ‘socialism or barbarism’, infighting will give rise to the latter. In order to effectively defeat the far-right, a united front is of the utmost importance. Corbyn and Polanski must not exist as competitors, but as allies. Real allies.
Image: Raph_PH via Flickr

