A-Level exam marking: a complete and utter farce
By Sophie Dawson
When it is drilled into you from the age of 11 that the exams you sit at the end of Year 13 essentially determine your entire future, you anticipate them to be marked with the appropriate skill, knowledge, care and attention. You hope that examiners, aware that their decisions are, in many ways, life-changing, receive adequate training and apply the mark scheme accurately. Clearly, these expectations are simply too much to ask.
I sat my A-Level exams in June. I’ve never worked harder for anything in my life. Having been predicted A*A*A*- and never achieving any less than this in what felt like an onslaught of rehearsal exams- I opened my envelope on that most fateful of mornings to A*AB and was devastated. Heartbroken, even. My actual words were, “These cannot be my results.” I faced comments from family, friends, namely, “A ‘B’ is a good grade,” and “You’ve still done excellently.” Yet to me, as somebody who attached far too much self-worth to her academic achievements, it felt as though I’d failed myself. Dramatic, maybe, but I saw absolutely nothing to be proud of.
After considerable deliberation, we requested a ‘review of marking’ of my AQA English Language, for which I was 5 marks away from an A. Upon this review, not only did my grade increase to an A, but my score for Paper 2 alone rose by 14 marks. From 65 to 79/100. Other candidates in my cohort, potentially impacted by such considerable errors, whether due to incorrect application of mark schemes, examiner burnout, or inexperience, were never made aware of possible discrepancies in the marking of their papers. I guess there simply aren’t the resources for wider investigations.
How many erroneously marked papers go overlooked, particularly when students do not have the financial means to justify the ludicrous cost for one to be reviewed? Notwithstanding, when they do not have an adult- a parent, a carer, a teacher- advocating for them? We paid £59.90 for one paper to be reviewed. It is elitist. It deliberately discriminates against working-class pupils. It is a disgrace. And we wonder why the North-South grade divide is widening.
Grades should not and do not define me
To exacerbate this absurdity, having never obtained below an A* in Politics (Edexcel), and being 8 marks away from this in my final exams, we requested a ‘review of marking’ for Papers 1 and 2. The result? I was downgraded to a B. My Paper 1 mark plummeted by 15. Confident that this was incorrect, and on the verge of an identity crisis, we pursued a post-results marking appeal, costing an additional £150. This time, I was awarded an additional 5 marks, and my grade returned to an A. Monies were reimbursed. Two senior examiners had been inaccurate in their marking. At that point, I was honestly too exasperated by, and mistrustful of, the entire debacle to care.
What kind of system is this? It is one in which I have absolutely no faith, that is for sure. It smacks of incompetence and corruption, and it should be scrapped. It is paradoxical, considering the academically demanding nature of A-Levels, and the carelessness with which they are evidently marked.
Luckily, my grades did not impact my place at Durham University to study Politics. I cannot say the same for others. How many higher education opportunities have been robbed from 17- and 18-year-olds because an examiner couldn’t be bothered? Because they were rushing after a long day of teaching? The injustice is blinding.
In one respect, results day taught me a lesson: my grades should not and do not define me. No matter how much significance schools, colleges and sixth forms across the country place upon them, A-Levels really are just a stepping stone from one stage of life to the next. However, it also made glaringly obvious how anachronistic our education system truly is. To me, it seemed as though my two years of determination and dedication were for nothing. Because in the end, it came down to an individual, sat behind a computer screen, who knew absolutely nothing about me nor my abilities, to assess- incorrectly, may I add- how well I could write an essay on a subject that is so much wider.
It rings true that the child does not fail the system; the system fails the child. Our system is broken, and it is the responsibility of this Government to repair it.
Image credit: Andy Barbour via Pexels

