You came, you shouted, but you didn’t conquer: a response from the original author
This article is a response to an earlier article by Clara Ohayon (Aidan’s JCR President), which itself was a response to Thomas Musson’s original piece.
Thomas Musson
I must admit, reading the response to my article cheered me up immensely. Trying to understand obscure German philosophy on a dull Monday afternoon is never interesting, but when this interruption to my study popped up on my laptop screen, it transformed a day of boredom into a new day of excitement. For this, I must thank the author of that article, yet that’s where my appreciation ends.
For those whose eyes are not regularly glued to Palatinate, you will require some much-needed context here. A couple of weeks previously, I wrote a small piece for Palatinate discussing my view on the student accommodation free protests.
I argued that the perennialism, pessimism and planning of these protests was lacking authenticity, not in the ideology that supports them, but in their facilitation by student representative bodies. These bodies have become primarily concerned with their own self-fulfilment, creating a cliquey culture of ‘tiresome [and] dull’ protests that symbolise their ineffective representation, and not serious student concern. In light of all this, I sought to encourage new and old students alike to rethink their views on these protests and pursue a new agenda – one of radical and dynamic engagement with our university.
I apologise for the tangent there, but context is extremely important, and in the case of this author’s article, notably missing, where instead of providing reasoned and contextual arguments, she has chosen a passive-aggressive approach, which mistakenly equates my non-personal disagreement to personal dissent.
Indeed, it puzzles me as to why the author would devote an entire article that voraciously defends her and her JCR’s reputation, when my article didn’t come close to that level of personal attack. Likewise, this author accuses me of ‘propos[ing] no answer’ to these central issues, and yet reading her work, I could ask the very same thing back. This attempt to ignore my article’s message, alongside making this discussion one of personal politics, forces me to readdress these issues and seek more post-clarification.
the author is wrongly suggesting that inclusivity and ‘non-cliquey-ness’ are synonymous.
I start by considering her comments on my claim that student representative bodies are cliquey. The author writes that as ‘Aidan’s JCR…is a student body of 1000 students, represented by about 100 democratically elected JCR Officers…anyone can run for election and everyone can vote’. Now I agree with this statement unreservedly, but the author is wrongly suggesting that inclusivity and ‘non-cliquey-ness’ are synonymous. By logical extension, she is arguing that even institutions like the Houses of Parliament aren’t cliquey, as ‘anyone can run for election’ – an obvious oxymoron don’t you think?
According to my trusty friend Yahoo, being in a clique is not about exclusive access but about exclusive ideology, which was the basis of my original article’s claim. I believe that our student representatives mistakenly tell their students that to become more like them is to become more successful, popular and powerful, which when merged with protests, results in a type of student engagement that serves to only self-perpetuate this original ideology, and not a fever for genuine change.
I too want us to think ‘big and boldly over how [we] can properly and authentically encourage students to protest for change’, but that starts by recognising the failings of the current system.
Secondly, throughout the author’s article, there is a misguided attempt to amalgamate my criticism of past accommodation fee protests to present or future ones today. Indeed, the author writes that ‘one protest will not suddenly freeze the fees but standing up to challenge an injustice is a moral imperative’, as if this contradicts my original claims. Quoting my original article, I too want us to think ‘big and boldly over how [we] can properly and authentically encourage students to protest for change’, but that starts by recognising the failings of the current system. The author gets stuck when she supports a tiresome protest-model that achieved barely anything, and yet simultaneously, wants to build a ‘great social movement’. You can’t be satisfied with both.
I don’t have space to cover every disagreement myself and the author share on the representative effectiveness of student common rooms, but besides that, we do share a similar drive to make our student protests one where ‘we will conquer eventually’. I cannot fault her on her JCR’s move to create a #rippedoff society, and I applaud her gauntlet-laying-challenge to me to get involved in this campaign. Yet for a number of crucial reasons in her review article, this author has made overwhelming mistakes:
Firstly, she has misunderstood the entirety of my article’s message, believing that I cynically ‘dismiss any call to action’, when I actually challenged us to ‘do something radical, dynamic, and actually life-changing.’ As an executive officer on St Aidan’s SCR and a Postgraduate Faculty Representative, my experience and my article was not an act of sitting back and judging, but instead, an act of stepping forward and challenging the status quo.
Secondly, in writing an article that lacks important context, the author has served to prove my point: student representative are too often cliquey and out of touch. Think about it: why write an article that contains only 1% of context if it was meant to be written for every student? Why accuse me of ‘propos[ing] no answer’ to these central issues, yet do exactly the same? If the author had wanted to write a response that focussed on the actual issues at hand that affect all students, she wouldn’t have misunderstood my article’s message.
I therefore encourage this author to not only read my work again, but to understand that we are ultimately arguing for the same thing.
We both want a radical and dynamic engagement with our university. To achieve this properly for every student, we shouldn’t argue with each other, but instead for everyone else.
Image by Tom Parnell via Flickr
