You came, you shouted, but you didn’t conquer: a response from a JCR President
By Clara Ohayon, Aidan’s JCR President
In October, the University announced a 3.5% rise in accommodation fees for the next academic year. Faced with this statement, the author of the article asks the right question, “What do we do?”. To this, however, he proposes no answer. Instead, he seems intent on denouncing the #rippedoff protest as “tiresome” and “weak”, condemning student representatives for their “lack of zeal”, for being “out of touch with the student body”, and calling out the DSU and JCRs alike for their cliquey-ness.
Using Aidan’s JCR as a model, I will attempt to show how student representation is serving its students, and extoll that the #rippedoff protests are on their way to making a tangible difference.
Aidan’s JCR: a clique?
According to my trusty friend Google, a clique is “a small close-knit group of people who do not readily allow others to join them”. Aidan’s JCR, on the other hand, is a student body of 1000 students, represented by about 100 democratically elected JCR Officers holding various positions across committees. Anyone can run for election and everyone can vote, meaning that if there were a clique, it would be one which Aidanites choose to self-perpetuate.
However, I understand that inclusivity does not solely consist in letting anyone join and participate. An environment is only effectively inclusive if everyone feels comfortable enough to take advantage of the opportunities they are presented with. This is why Aidan’s JCR strives to actively reach out to everyone. While campaigning for the protest, Aidan’s freps and I didn’t only tell students to join, we made people feel welcome by discussing the issue over dinner, and on a bar crawl we organised.

The #rippedoff protest: useless, “dull and weak”?
The author seems to think that the #rippedoff protest as organized by people who are either foolish enough to think a single protest will be effective, or cynical enough not to care about the protest’s outcome. I’d like to think that JCR committees are neither.
One protest will not suddenly freeze the fees but standing up to challenge an injustice is a moral imperative regardless of the consequences. More pragmatically, Rome was not built in a day and nor is a campaign. The author calls for radical action yet is shocked by the fact that the protest was “pre-planned”. However, any great social movement requires planning.
For example, the 2015 UCL rent strike was but the culmination of a series of actions which demanded careful preparation. Rationally escalating the conflict in this manner had the dual benefit of ensuring UCL took this student movement seriously all the while allowing the campaign to build up its support base and grab the attention of the press. Radical action requires careful planning and the creation of a network of committed supporters. While the author awaits a deus ex machina, I will strive to work on developing the latter.
The author also asserts that the #rippedoff call to arms has not been answered. However, the size of the crowd last Friday compared to past protests means that we are succeeding in building momentum long-term.
“Student representative bodies: out of touch with students”?
The author here taps into the classic populist idea that the people who represent you don’t understand you. To call student representatives out of touch is to argue that they lack information and that they don’t have sympathy for students, neither of which is true for reasons too obvious to describe.
Here is what I promise, and here is my call to arms – come, shout, and we will conquer eventually. Or sit down, write a vacuous article and dismiss any call to action. Being cynical is intellectually lazy. Insulting the #rippedoff protest perpetuates the status quo.
If the author wants something radical and effective, then I invite him to help Aidan’s JCR garner support for the #rippedoff campaign.
If the author thinks the JCR is cliquey then I invite him to run for a position and see for himself that it isn’t. If the author wants to see passionate students discussing Aidan’s long-term #rippedoff strategy then he should show up to the next St Aidan’s Ripped Off society meeting. But this, of course, requires to come and to shout.
Photographs: ADTeasdale and Nathan Keirn via Flickr
