Writing: pleasure or pain?

Recently the Irish novelist Colm Tóibín hit the headlines by moaning on about the arduous and woe-betrodden life of the writer. “Oh there’s no pleasure”, claimed Tóibín in an interview for the online journal the Manchester Review. “I write with a sort of grim determination to deal with things that are hidden and difficult and this means, I think, that pleasure is out of the question.”

The notion of writing as a painful task found its apotheosis in Flaubert pursuing his monkish existence, wreathed in smoke and forever attempting to hit upon le mot juste with which he might ever so slowly start filling a page or two.

Since then, every serious, browbeaten ‘literary’ artiste has never been shy of professing how much they have suffered for their art. There are stories of Martin Amis taking two days of unceasing rumination over the simple task of describing a piece of bread, or Samuel Beckett almost reduced to scratching out his dramas in blood.

It was the foolhardy Anthony Trollope who admitted in his autobiography that he worked to a schedule and wrote for money. No sooner had the words entered the public sphere than his reputation found itself being unceremoniously ripped to pieces by the critical establishment. >>>They claimed that it was impossible that the Muse could work to a schedule or be used to procure pecuniary rewards. In order to be a truly great writer you needed to follow nothing less than a marriage-ending, child-estranging, hermetic existence to ever have a chance of entering the literary hall of fame.

Last week, Tóibín’s comments sparked a debate in the Guardian where several semi-known, and a healthy smattering of unknown, novelists offered their view on the trials and tribulations of ever scooping up the authorial pen. The popular thrillmaster Hani Kunzru claimed that “I get great pleasure from writing, but not always, or even usually”, a happy taster for the self-serving whines that followed. Amit Chaudhuri – a writer I cheerfully admit to never having heard of – admitted that “Writing novels is no fun; nor is, generally speaking, reading novels.

Reading people writing about novels is not always fun either, because relatively little of this kind of writing is any good. Then there’s the group of people who don’t enjoy being novelists, to which I probably belong; whose lives are at once shaped and defined by, and to some extent entrapped in, the act of writing fiction.”

Thankfully, amidst this eternal pit of depressive unfunness, there were a few positivistic souls who admitted to gaining greater job satisfaction. Will Self, one of the minority among all the contributors to have prostituted himself on – heaven forbid – TV, said that “I gain nothing but pleasure from writing fiction”, while Julie Myerson (again, only the second scribbler famous or interesting enough to be allowed coverage to the wider public) concurred that “Writing gives me such enormous pleasure, and I’m a much happier (and therefore nicer) person when I’m doing it”.

To be honest it’s hard to have any time for the other miserable, moping, bottle-clutching, pill-imbibing lot as the one thing the world most certainly doesn’t need any more of is books.

If Chaudhuri and his cohorts really hate writing so much, why don’t they just give up? The first to go on the worldwide cull of extraneous print and paper cloggage must be the ones responsible for casting a pall of boredom and weariness over the literary scene. Books and literature are never going to appear exciting and fun if the authors themselves find the whole thing nap-inducing.

So surely the simple answer to Colm Tóibín must be “get another job!” Perhaps someone more appreciative of the rewards should be allowed to take his place on the shelves. In these cash-scarce times the absence of a new Tóibín novel is hardly going to be a world-wobbling catastrophe.

For me the great writers seem to have an exuberant quality about them. With Chaucer, Shakespeare and Dickens, comic invention is bubbling over from every scene. You can sense the relish with which they attacked the page. They create a world full of fun, drama and enjoyment, a fascination with the complexities of the world.

For many modern writers such enthusiasm would seem positively commercial, a stain on their hard-won literary credentials. Even with the stylistic assiduity of Nabokov there is always an impish twinkle behind the faultlessly filigreed prose; he never commits the arch crime of dullness, unlike the majority of his modern followers.

Refugees in Africa, political dissidents in Zimbabwe and families in Iraq might well have something to complain about, but bestselling writers, I’d venture to suggest, do not..