Flying high

Funny Girl
Trevelyan Musical Society
Trevelyan Buttery

Don’t tell me not to live, just sit and potter. Life’s candy and the sun’s a bowl of butter”. Ah yes, the mantra of every happy-go-lucky Durhamite as they make their way to lectures on a Monday morning. And coincidentally also the immortal words first spoken by Barbara Streisand back in 1968 when she played opposite Omar Sharif in the film adaptation of Lennart’s Broadway musical Funny Girl.

The Trevs dining room doesn’t lend itself brilliantly to stage performances – it is very long, very thin, not famed for its acoustic excellence, and doesn’t accommodate audience members who enjoy being able to see the performers throughout the show. Nevertheless, as the house lights dipped and the orchestral notes rang out over a packed audience, my cynicism was laid to rest.

Transporting their audience to pre-WW1 New York, the production opened in typically ostentatious fashion as the chorus sprang into life, engaging audience members by utilising the space well. However, the speech was sporadically inaudible, with sound problems evident from the outset: that which I could hear was often mumbled. I found solace in the hope that after a shaky opening night, the team were experiencing those famous ‘second night blues’.

When we first meet our protagonist, Fanny Brice, she is a stage-struck teen fighting to ‘make it big’ in the world of showbusiness. Her charm and humour are very much present, and in that unconventional, endearingly left-of-centre manner which means that she won’t have become nauseatingly saccharine by the time the heady finale comes a-knocking: the blueprint, in other words, for every decent musical from My Fair Lady to Evita and back again via 42nd Street. Poor girl turned rich and all that jazz.

Then she finally gets her big break. Cue the love interest, this time in the form of Nick Arnstein, a tall, dark, handsome stranger who enters into her life like the breeze through a green room door, only to sweep her off her high-heeled feet before she can say ‘emancipation’. Naturally he is deliciously suave, articulate, wealthy, and superior to her only in ego size, despite her rose-tinted illusions to the contrary.

Heading proceedings was Alex Walshaw, and what a delight she was. Her voice was, at times, breathtaking, her elegance and stage presence demanded our attention, and she consistently maintained precisely the brand of infectious energy characterised by her role. It was a shame the same couldn’t always be said for the cast.

Many of the performers failed to convince me that they were even engaged in the performance, let alone enjoying it. This left me decidedly underwhelmed by the end of many of the numbers. Sam Watkinson, playing the Nick Arnstein to her Fanny Brice, gave an occasionally wooden but otherwise highly praiseworthy performance. His character wasn’t quite as captivating as his leading lady – but then he’s not supposed to be, otherwise she’d end up with him.

A word must be spared for Polly Aldridge, who consistently sparkled in her portrayal of fussy housewife Mrs Brice. Her role wasn’t one of the most central but she frequently dominated the scenes that she was in. The remainder of the cast displayed much merit as an ensemble and were sufficiently versatile within that capacity to transpose roles when the need arose. But there’s more to musicals than jazz hands and spirit fingers, and these guys were often let down by poor choreography.

As the evening progressed, the occurrence of cluttered or messy-looking staging increased, with a frustrating neglect of the fine art of blocking. So many elemental aspects were in place to secure the show’s success – the costumes, music and lighting were all superb – and I was willing these to be vindicated with similarly outstanding acting. But I’m sorry to say it just didn’t happen. I say this with some hesitation. The acting wasn’t abysmal (and here I include the Bronx accents) by any stretch of the imagination – and we’re talking about a musical whose cast was comprised entirely from a single, small, college: a feat in itself considering the notoriously demanding nature of this musical. If anything, I was struck by how many talented performers featured amongst the Trevs folk. There is a lot to be said for the work of Director Maria Pipkin in bringing the show to life – not every college could have pulled something of this scale out of the bag, and there’s much to be said for the abundance of enthusiasm amongst them.

The combination of fantastic aesthetic appeal and a slick, practiced score from the band raised the overall quality of the show significantly. My toes saw their fair share of tapping action and I did find myself absentmindedly humming Don’t Rain On My Parade as I crossed Kingsgate Bridge the next day (and not just because of the North East’s absurd precipitation patterns).

I’d be lying if I said I didn’t enjoy my night on the hill. It takes some incentive to get a Bailey girl like myself to venture up that cardiac monstrosity out of office hours, but despite my qualms it’s not a stretch to imagine that I’d put my stilettos through the walk again.